Everyone has a story about the perfect slice. Maybe it was that impossibly thin crust after a long day, or the gentle tug of mozzarella when you lifted the first piece. In Ridge, NY, the right pie can feel like an old friend—warm, satisfying, and always finding a way to surprise you. Having spent more evenings than I care to admit taste-testing my way across town, it’s fair to say I’ve got a few opinions on which shops actually deliver the full pizza experience.
Finding the best pizza in Ridge is about much more than melted cheese and spicy sauce. It’s about knowing which spots put care into every pie and which ones keep their recipes classic but never stale. If you want to save yourself from disappointment while hunting for a solid pepperoni or the most delicate margherita, let this guide steer your appetite in the right direction.
Where to find the best pizza in Ridge, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Ridge, NY:
- Alfredo’s Pizza
- Alfredo’s Pizza & Restaurant
- PizzAmore
- Cafe Rosa Pizzeria
- Middle Island Pizza
- Pelligrino Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Carlo’s Pizza Manorville
- Pompei Pizza Restaurant
- Domino’s Pizza
1. Alfredo’s Pizza
Alfredo’s Pizza brings Ridge locals back time and again with its grand mix of comfort and quality. Step inside and you’re greeted by the scent of dough rising, a sign that each pie gets attention from start to finish. The service is friendly without fuss, making you feel like a regular—even if it’s your first time.
The standout here is the classic cheese pizza—crisp edge, light chew, balanced sauce. It’s the kind of slice you crave at odd hours, and Alfredo’s never disappoints. Their veggie pies are fresh, never soggy, and offer a real showcase for their kitchen’s care with toppings.
If you’re in the mood for something hearty, their Sicilian is thick, golden, and packed with flavor. Takeout holds up just as well at home. For a dependable Ridge pizza fix, it’s tough to top Alfredo’s.
2. Alfredo’s Pizza & Restaurant
Alfredo’s Pizza & Restaurant feels like the spot where locals gather after a big game or a late workday, hungry for something familiar and good. There’s table service if you want to slow down and enjoy a meal, or takeout if you want to keep it casual at home. Either way, you’re in for quality pizza with generous toppings.
Their margherita pizza is a local staple—tangy tomato and basil balanced by oozy mozzarella. Pair it with a crisp, house-made salad and you’ve got a dinner worth making a tradition. I always find the crust light but never dull, with just the right snap.
The vegetarian-friendly menu means everyone can share a table here. Don’t miss their veggie-loaded pies, proof that simple ingredients can shine. Alfredo’s manages comfort food with a little extra polish.
3. PizzAmore
PizzAmore is the sort of place that makes pizza night feel a little special. The menu covers all the essentials, but there’s a bit of flair here—thin crust that crackles, toppings that look chosen by hand, and slices that never feel weighed down. Even after a busy workday, a stop here lifts your mood.
Their white pizza gets my vote for best surprise—creamy, garlicky, and finished with just enough ricotta. I always notice it packs flavor without being heavy. For more classic tastes, the plain cheese is spot on, and there’s a gentle spice in the sauce that keeps you coming back.
PizzAmore stands out for consistency, especially with timing and quality. Grab a pie before heading to the park. It holds up perfectly, slice after slice.
4. Cafe Rosa Pizzeria
(631) 775-9192Call
Cafe Rosa Pizzeria may look understated from the outside, but once inside you’ll find it cozy and inviting. I’ve dropped by for a quick lunch, only to linger, drawn in by the aroma and easy pace that makes you forget the day’s rush. Staff greet you like you’re already a regular, and the atmosphere nudges you to relax a bit.
Their grandma slice is a standout—not too thick, not too thin, with a perfect crisp bite and a bright, garlicky tomato sauce. If you’re in the mood for something classic, their plain cheese does the trick, and you can really taste the freshness in every ingredient.
Cafe Rosa’s pizzas prove that simple techniques and care make all the difference. This is where you find details that matter, from the crust to the final sprinkle of herbs.
5. Middle Island Pizza
Middle Island Pizza sits just down the road from Ridge, but it’s worth the short drive for anyone who takes their pizza seriously. I’ve popped in on busy weekends and still left impressed by the service and attention to detail. The place manages to blend old-school pizzeria charm with a sense of occasion.
Their specialty is a robust, classic New York–style pie—thin crust, slightly chewy, and always with a flavorful sauce that lifts every bite. I keep coming back for their veggie pizza, which stays crisp and never rubbery, with a generous brush of olive oil that works wonders.
Middle Island’s menu leans into quality ingredients and generous portions. If you’re looking for a pizza that feels both substantial and memorable, this is the spot to try first.
6. Pelligrino Pizza
Pelligrino Pizza in Shoreham has a loyal following, and after my first visit, I saw why. The staff run things smoothly, and there’s an easy rhythm to the place that puts you at ease right away. The menu is tight, focused, and clearly built around pizza done right.
Their traditional pies hit all the right notes—airy crust, gently charred edges, and a sauce that tastes like summer tomatoes. I always nudge friends to try the white pizza, which arrives bubbling with ricotta and a hint of roasted garlic. Each bite feels balanced, with nothing overpowering the basics.
Pelligrino stands out for the craftsmanship in each pie. It’s a great example of how a local spot can win you over with simplicity and confidence on the dough.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Middle Island brings a familiar comfort for those moments when you crave predictability. Sometimes, there’s nothing better than knowing exactly how your stuffed crust or pan pizza will taste. After many late-night gatherings, their delivery has come through fast and hot, which certainly wins points in my book.
The classic pan pizza stands out—crisp, thick, and rich on the bottom, yet light up top with melty cheese. When you want that signature bite and a hearty sauce, it hits the mark every time. Meat-free options, like the veggie lover’s pie, always have a decent crunch and flavor balance.
Consistency and convenience are the draw at Pizza Hut. Their online ordering and carryout make it easy to grab a pie when you need it simple and satisfying.
8. Carlo’s Pizza Manorville
Carlo’s Pizza Manorville is often my top choice when I want a break from big-name chains. The shop has a homey feel, with genuine service and a sense of pride in every pie. Each visit, you’ll find regulars popping by for their favorites and staff who remember your name.
The New York–style slice here is a must—foldable, a little chewy, and the kind of crust that holds up under solid layers of cheese. Their grandma pizza gets plenty of love too, with a slightly caramelized bottom and a burst of fresh tomato up top.
What sets Carlo’s apart is how they nail the essentials—good dough, fresh toppings, and sauce that isn’t just an afterthought. It’s a place that does pizza the right way, every time.
9. Pompei Pizza Restaurant
Pompei Pizza Restaurant feels like a hidden gem for those who want more than just a fast slice. The atmosphere is lively but never hectic, and the staff manages a steady stream of regulars with genuine warmth. I’ve dropped by around dinner and always left impressed by the prompt service and perfectly cooked pies.
The brick oven pizza is the highlight—thin but sturdy, with a smoky flavor that adds depth. Their margherita delivers on freshness and balance, while the veggie options taste genuinely farm-fresh. If you’re in the mood for something classic, their plain cheese lets the dough and sauce speak for themselves.
Pompei stands out for attention to detail and a steady hand with ingredients. It’s the kind of spot you end up recommending to friends after just one visit.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Rocky Point is where you turn when you want predictability without missing out on comfort. As someone who’s had their fair share of late-night pizza runs, Domino’s always fits the bill for reliable delivery and convenient pickup. The app makes ordering a breeze, and you’re rarely left waiting long.
The Hand Tossed pizza is consistently the best choice—chewy, sturdy, and layered with a tangy sauce that never overwhelms. The thin crust is a close runner-up, perfect for anyone who wants something lighter but still loaded with toppings.
Domino’s holds its own with customization options and deals. Go for the veggie pizzas or create your own, knowing each pie will arrive hot and exactly as you ordered.
More Things to Try in Ridge, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Ridge, NY?
Some local favorites include Alfredo’s Pizza, PizzAmore, Cafe Rosa Pizzeria, Middle Island Pizza, and Pelligrino Pizza. Each shop brings something unique—whether it’s a classic New York slice or specialty pies.
Are there vegetarian pizza options in Ridge, NY?
Yes. Several local spots, like Alfredo’s Pizza & Restaurant and PizzAmore, offer freshly-made vegetarian pizzas loaded with seasonal veggies and flavorful sauces.
Which pizza spots offer delivery or takeout?
Most pizzerias in Ridge, including Domino’s, Pizza Hut, and Alfredo’s, provide delivery and takeout services. Online ordering is usually quick and hassle-free.
What’s the most popular pizza style in Ridge, NY?
New York–style pizza leads the pack—thin, foldable slices with crisp edges. Some pizzerias also offer Sicilian, grandma, and white pizzas for variety.
Are there any pizzerias with dine-in service in Ridge, NY?
Yes, several spots like Alfredo’s Pizza & Restaurant and Cafe Rosa Pizzeria have dine-in seating if you prefer to enjoy your pie fresh from the oven.