A good slice of pizza travels faster than small town gossip in Nyack. If you’ve ever stood on Main Street, juggling a warm box while the scent of melted cheese clings to your coat, you know there’s an art to finding the real deal. This town isn’t short on character, and its pizzerias proudly reflect that quirk—a patchwork of old family recipes, crispy crusts, and bubbling sauces.
Picking the best pizza in Nyack comes down to more than just what’s hot out of the oven. Over the years, I’ve tasted everything from foldable New York slices to old-world margheritas topped with basil that’s fresher than your cousin at Thanksgiving. Some contenders deliver a rustic charm you won’t find in a chain. Others have that neighborhood buzz—the kind where the owners know your name and your order. If you’re after a slice that’s full of stories and serious flavor, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best pizza in Nyack, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Nyack, NY:
- Turiello Pizza House & Restaurant
- Tarantella Pizzaria
- Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Pizza Bistro
- Domino’s Pizza
- Amici Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Brickhouse Food & Drink
- Tarantella Restaurant & Pizzeria
- Capri Pizza & Pasta
- Stella Luna
1. Turiello Pizza House & Restaurant
Turiello Pizza House & Restaurant, perched right on Main Street, is a fixture in Nyack. Slices here have a way of pulling you back for more, thanks to their thin, crisp crust and just the right hit of tang in the sauce. The energy is classic pizzeria: fast-moving, nostalgic, yet always welcoming.
One bite of their plain cheese slice and you get why locals stay loyal. The balance is spot on—gooey cheese, lightly charred edges, and crust that bends, not breaks. For something special, try the white pizza with garlic and fresh tomato; it’s a simple dish, but it perfectly showcases Turiello’s style—unpretentious but memorable.
Vegetarian and gluten-free options get the same attention here, so no one misses out on the pizza tour.
2. Tarantella Pizzaria
Step into Tarantella Pizzaria and you’ll find a spot buzzing with both locals and newcomers. This isn’t just pizza; it’s a family-run tradition that feels woven into the town itself. The space is comfy, the service is quick, and slices move from oven to table before you’ve finished your thoughts.
Every time I’ve dropped in, the Margherita pizza stands out with its gently blistered crust and bright tomato flavor. For a richer bite, the Grandma slice wins hearts—thick, yet somehow airy, with sweet sauce and fresh basil.
Vegetarian options get top billing here, and late-night hours mean a great pie is never out of reach. Tarantella captures the neighborhood warmth that makes Nyack pizza unique.
3. Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria
Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria sits tucked in the Hub Shopping Center, but what’s coming out of their kitchen is anything but ordinary. This is where comfort and freshness meet. You’ll notice every table seems to be in the middle of sharing a good story over an even better pie.
On my last visit, I went straight for their classic Neapolitan pizza. The crust was just chewy enough, the sauce had an inviting sweetness, and the cheese was creamy without being overwhelming. There’s a warmth to their food and the staff—dishes always land at your table with a little extra attention.
If you’re craving something heartier, try the Vegetarian pizza. It arrives loaded, but never soggy, and each bite feels like a step up from your old favorites.
4. Pizza Bistro
+1 845-358-4811
Pizza Bistro sits quietly on South Broadway, but its pies speak loud and clear. This is the place where cravings get answered with bold flavors and blistered crusts. Step inside and you’ll find a cozy vibe that doesn’t try too hard—just lets the pizza do the talking.
I once grabbed a quick lunch here and found the Veggie Pie full of roasted peppers and mushrooms, each slice generously topped but not overloaded. Their sauce has just enough zing to hold its own, whether you go classic or adventurous.
The Margherita pizza is a must-try: simple, fragrant, and exactly what you need if you’re serious about your crust. Lunch or dinner, Pizza Bistro is always a safe bet.
5. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza in Nyack is where convenience and consistency meet. If you want your pizza fast, hot, and just the way you ordered, the team here rarely misses a beat. The online ordering is nothing short of smooth—you can customize a pie down to the last detail and track it from oven to doorstep.
I’ve leaned on Domino’s during late-night cravings and busy weeknights. The Thin Crust Veggie pizza delivers a crackly base with plenty of crunch, while the Classic Hand Tossed cheese is always dependable and gooey. When I’m in a share-it-all mood, the Parmesan Stuffed Crust pulls in extra flavor without going overboard.
Vegetarian choices are easy to spot, making group orders a breeze. Domino’s may be a chain, but the staff here ensures every pizza still feels like a personal creation.
6. Amici Restaurant & Pizzeria
Amici Restaurant & Pizzeria has carved out its place in Nyack’s pizza landscape for more than two decades. This is the kind of spot where families gather and regulars linger. From my first visit, I was struck by how every pie feels like it’s made with genuine care and a personal touch.
The Classic Cheese Pizza here is a full embrace of what pizza should be—soft, crisp, and anchored by a flavorful sauce. Their crust walks the line between chewy and charred, hitting just the right note for every slice. For something extra, their specialty veggie-topped pizzas bring a fresh edge to tradition.
It’s rare to leave Amici without feeling like part of their extended family. This is comfort food in its true form.
7. Brickhouse Food & Drink
Brickhouse Food & Drink offers more than just a place to eat; it’s where good friends and great pizza meet under one roof. The vibe is lively without being overly crowded, and the exposed brick walls almost seem to promise a satisfying meal. There’s a welcome warmth here, even when you’re grabbing a slice solo.
On my last stop, the Four Cheese Pizza turned a quick lunch into something memorable. The blend of cheeses melted into pockets of rich, sharp flavor atop a crust that’s crackly around the edges yet soft at the center. Their vegetable pies are worth exploring as well—colorful, hearty, and never shy on toppings.
Brickhouse keeps things laid back and genuine, which only adds to the appeal after a stroll along South Broadway.
8. Tarantella Restaurant & Pizzeria
Tarantella Restaurant & Pizzeria has a familiar hum—something about the bustle here is instantly inviting. This spot is perfect for those who appreciate a pizza that blends tradition and creativity. Whether you’re dining with friends or just raiding the takeout menu, there’s always something that catches your attention.
I’m partial to their Margherita pizza, which gets the basics extremely right: vibrant tomato sauce, milky mozzarella, and fresh basil layered on a crust that’s got enough bite to keep things interesting. Their Vegetable Pizza goes above and beyond, layering roasted veggies generously for a satisfying, wholesome pie.
Tarantella’s staff know their regulars by name, and it’s easy to see why people keep coming back for more of the good stuff.
9. Capri Pizza & Pasta
Capri Pizza & Pasta might sit just outside of Nyack, but its pizza deserves a mention for anyone who takes pie seriously. The team here works with quality ingredients and it shows in every slice. The vibe is inviting, whether you’re sitting down for a meal or calling in for takeout after a long day.
On a recent visit, I dove into their Vegetable Pizza. What stood out was the crisp crust that could support a hefty layer of fresh toppings—nothing greasy or soggy, just actual flavor and texture. Pasta dishes tempt as well, but the pizza menu stays front and center, balancing tradition and boldness.
Capri’s balance of comfort and quality makes it easy to see why people come back for seconds. For a satisfying, classic pizza in the Nyack area, this spot delivers.
10. Stella Luna
(845) 359-6040Call
Stella Luna in Orangetown Shopping Center is known for channeling that neighborhood pizzeria energy—friendly faces, quick service, and pizza that hits the spot. It’s the kind of place you stumble into once and keep returning, lured by both the smell and the genuine welcome.
From my first visit, I realized the Grandma Pizza at Stella Luna wasn’t just another square. It’s crisp at the base, sweet with sauce, and piled with precisely the right amount of cheese. For a more classic taste, their plain cheese slice lets the balance and fresh ingredients shine.
Stella Luna is a reminder that genuineness goes a long way. It stands out with honest flavors and unfussy comfort.
More Things to Try in Nyack, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the best pizza place in Nyack for classic New York-style slices?
Turiello Pizza House & Restaurant is a local favorite for foldable, crisp New York-style slices loaded with flavor and nostalgia.
Where can I find vegetarian or gluten-free pizza in Nyack?
Tarantella Pizzaria and Amici Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria offer vegetarian and gluten-free options, keeping diverse eaters in mind.
Is there a place in Nyack to grab pizza late at night?
Tarantella Pizzaria is open late, making it a solid stop for pizza cravings after hours.
Can I get pizza delivered in Nyack?
Absolutely. Local pizza shops like Domino’s offer online delivery, and many local spots, including Turiello and Tarantella, also offer delivery and takeout.
Which pizzeria downtown has the best atmosphere for eating in?
If you want to linger, Brickhouse Food & Drink combines good pizza with a laid-back, inviting atmosphere perfect for dining in.