Finding stellar pizza in Manhasset, NY isn’t just about dough and toppings—it’s about uncovering those slices that make you pause mid-bite, look up, and wonder why every other pizza can’t taste like this. Over time, I’ve sat at corner booths, chatted with locals, and even debated thin crust versus Sicilian with delivery drivers. Manhasset has its share of hidden gems and old-school classics, each with their own charm and fiercely loyal patrons.
Manhasset is more than just a pit-stop for pizza—it’s a small town with big flavor. I’ve scoured menus, tasted everything from pillowy fresh mozzarella to crackling, wood-fired crusts, and narrowed down the spots that consistently deliver. Whether you’re searching for a quick lunch fix or a new family favorite, you’re about to discover pizzerias worth sharing. If you’ve ever tasted pizza that made you reconsider your standards, you’re in the right place.
Where to find the best pizza in Manhasset, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Manhasset, NY:
- Villa Milano
- Gino’s Pizza
- Umberto’s
- Cipollini Pronto
- Billy Dees Pizzeria
- Randazzo of Manhasset
- Antonino’s
- Papa Johns Pizza
- Bocconcini Pizzeria
- Grimaldi’s Pizza
1. Villa Milano
Villa Milano on Plandome Road feels like a cozy Italian escape in the heart of Manhasset. The first time I stopped in, the aroma of fresh basil and blistered crust drew me in before I even looked at the menu. Here, the pizzas do all the talking.
The Margherita Pizza is a stand-out—crisp yet tender crust, balanced sauce, and creamy mozzarella. For something heartier, the Sicilian slice is thick, golden-edged, and perfect for sharing. They even have gluten free bases and vegan options, earning them a loyal following.
What truly sets Villa Milano apart is their attention to detail; every pizza feels carefully crafted rather than rushed. If you’re after real flavor, it’s hard to beat their pies in Manhasset.
2. Gino’s Pizza
Gino’s Pizza sits right at the heart of Manhasset’s main strip. The place buzzes with regulars who know the staff by name, and there’s always the cheerful sound of slices being served. My own introduction to Gino’s involved a classic plain slice, piping hot and gloriously cheesy, and I’ve been hooked ever since.
Their pizza stands out for its balance—crispy crust, a tangy yet mellow sauce, and cheese that actually stretches without sliding off. The vegetable slice is a personal favorite, stacked with seasonal veggies and always fresh.
If you crave no-fuss, classic New York pizza, Gino’s delivers every time. Grab a slice, and you’ll understand the love locals have for this spot.
3. Umberto’s
Umberto’s in Manhasset brings a slice of Italian tradition to Plandome Road. The two-story space channels rustic Tuscan vibes, but it’s the food that truly steals the show. On my first visit, I gave in to the hype and ordered their signature Grandma pizza—one soft, crunchy bite and every recommendation suddenly made sense.
The Grandma Pizza is the main event. With a thin, crisp base, tangy tomato sauce, and just the right touch of cheese, it’s easy to see why it earned a spot on The Food Network. For something more adventurous, Umberto’s Special—or a simple Margherita—displays their no-shortcut approach to quality.
What sets Umberto’s apart is authenticity and consistency. You’ll leave with a new pizza standard.
4. Cipollini Pronto
Cipollini Pronto puts a modern spin on classic Italian pizza, right in the Americana shopping center. One lunch break here started as a quick bite but turned into a leisurely meal thanks to the lively atmosphere and fresh flavors. The café style lets you grab a pizza and get right back to window shopping or people watching.
Their Bianca pizza shines—ultra-thin crust, a light layer of creamy cheese, and a sprinkle of garlic that keeps it simple and irresistible. The Margherita is bright, fresh, and never weighed down with grease.
Cipollini Pronto stands out for its mix of convenience and quality. The menu is focused, so every slice is given attention. If you want pizza with flair and speed, this is the spot to visit.
5. Billy Dees Pizzeria
(516) 439-4438Call
Billy Dees Pizzeria brings a touch of neighborhood warmth to Manhasset’s pizza scene. The first time I walked in, the staff greeted me like a regular, which set the stage for a friendly, relaxed meal. The menu leans toward classic comfort but always with a twist that keeps things interesting.
Their cheese pizza stands out—golden crust, gooey but not messy cheese, and a sauce that’s just the right amount of tangy. Want something with more punch? Try a veggie-topped pie for fresh flavors and a satisfying bite.
Billy Dees is all about reliable, quality pizza with a homey feel. Whether you’re grabbing a quick slice or settling in for dinner, expect a meal that hits the spot every time.
6. Randazzo of Manhasset
(516) 439-5666Call
Randazzo of Manhasset might look unassuming from the street, but what happens inside is pure pizza chemistry. My first slice here was an eye-opener—the crisp base and rich sauce tasted like someone really cared about the details. It’s the kind of spot where you expect a solid pie, but you end up genuinely impressed.
The Sicilian pizza is their hidden gem, with a thick crust that’s airy but never doughy and a generous spread of robust tomato sauce. If you’re a fan of veggie toppings, their garden-fresh approach makes every slice bright and flavorful.
Randazzo sets itself apart by combining speedy service with pizza that doesn’t cut corners. For a classic experience with extra character, this place tops the list.
7. Antonino’s
(516) 627-0660Call
Antonino’s sits just off Northern Blvd and brings a bit of continental flair to Manhasset’s pizza scene. My first visit felt more like a night out than a quick dinner—think white tablecloths, attentive service, and a menu that goes beyond red sauce basics.
Their wood-fired pizzas are the real highlight. If you’re in the mood for something refined, try the classic Margherita or the veggie-topped Primavera. Each pizza arrives with a crisp crust, a balanced blend of cheese and sauce, and a whisper of char from the oven.
Antonino’s stands out for its elegant vibe and well-crafted pies, making it perfect for both special occasions and relaxed family meals.
8. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns Pizza might be a chain, but it’s the go-to when cravings hit fast in Manhasset and nearby. When a sudden pizza need struck one late evening, their familiar setup delivered—literally and figuratively. The dough was fresh, the tomato sauce a bit sweet, and every bite was reliably satisfying.
Their cheese pizza is the staple, rich, simple, and gooey without feeling overdone. Customize it with extra veggies or opt for the Garden Fresh, a solid pick packed with flavor and crunch.
Papa Johns stands out for consistency and value. If you’re after quick delivery and a taste you know and trust, this spot nails both every time.
9. Bocconcini Pizzeria
Bocconcini Pizzeria in Little Neck makes you feel at home before you order. My first visit was spur-of-the-moment, and the friendly staff had no trouble recommending the best slices. There’s a cozy neighborhood feel and no rush—just honest food and relaxed energy.
The Bocconcini Special pizza is the way to go. Generous toppings meet a chewy, yet airy crust, and every bite has a clean homemade taste. Their veggie slice is crisp and packed with fresh flavor, which says a lot about the freshness of their ingredients.
Bocconcini stands out for its low-key atmosphere and reliable pies. If you want a local spot with fair prices and full flavor, this pizzeria deserves a visit.
10. Grimaldi’s Pizza
(718) 819-2133Call
Grimaldi’s Pizza in Little Neck offers a classic, no-frills experience that’s all about the slice. The coal brick-oven makes a clear difference—their crusts come out with just the right amount of chew and a smoky char that’s tough to find elsewhere. My first bite of their pizza made it clear why locals keep coming back.
Try the classic Margherita pizza for a perfect blend of tangy tomato, creamy melted mozzarella, and that unforgettable coal-fired finish. Every bite delivers a satisfying mix of crisp and tender, rich yet never heavy.
Grimaldi’s stands apart for its mastery of time-honored technique and quality ingredients. If your pizza cravings call for old-school flavor, this spot hits all the right notes.
More Things to Try in Manhasset, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Manhasset, NY?
Manhasset has a strong lineup. Top choices include Villa Milano, Gino’s Pizza, Umberto’s, and Billy Dees Pizzeria. Each offers something unique, whether you prefer traditional New York slices or specialty pies.
Do pizzerias in Manhasset offer vegetarian or vegan options?
Yes. Most spots, including Villa Milano and Cipollini Pronto, offer vegetarian pizzas and even some vegan or gluten free crusts. It’s worth checking menus or asking when you order.
Can I get pizza delivered in Manhasset?
Absolutely. Nearly all pizzerias in the area, from larger names like Papa Johns to local favorites like Gino’s, offer delivery and takeout.
Is there a place for a sit-down pizza meal with family?
Definitely. Antonino’s, Umberto’s, and Villa Milano all offer a full dining experience, making them great picks for family dinners or special occasions.
Are there any gluten free pizza options in Manhasset?
Yes, several pizzerias provide gluten free options. Villa Milano is a standout if you’re looking for gluten free crusts or menu choices.