Finding the best pizza in Kingston, NY is more than a casual hunt for a quick slice. It’s a journey through crackling crusts, bubbling cheese, and the kind of tomato sauce that hints someone’s nonna just strolled out of the kitchen. Kingston surprises even the most seasoned pizza lovers. Imagine sunlight streaming through a window, laughter bouncing off the walls, and that first bite that makes you forget the day’s grind.
I’ve wandered Kingston’s main streets and tucked-away corners, popping into both beloved old-school pizzerias and ambitious newcomers. The city serves up pies that range from classic New York slices to wood-fired experiments that flirt with modern tastes. If you want a satisfying bite—without the fuss or a plane ticket to Italy—every spot here is vetted, tasted, and time-tested. Ready for a deep dive into cheesy glory? Let’s explore where your next favorite pizza is waiting.
Where to find the best pizza in Kingston, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Kingston, NY:
- La Florentina Restaurant
- Picnic Pizza
- Di Bella’s Pizza Shop
- Vincenzo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
- A Slice of Italy
- Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza
- King’s Pizza Restaurant
- Tony’s Pizzeria
- Savona Plaza Pizza
- Steve’s Pizza and Deli
1. La Florentina Restaurant
Tucked along Ulster Avenue, La Florentina Restaurant feels like a well-kept secret. The aroma of fresh dough lures you in, but it’s the wood-fired oven that really delivers. Watching pizzas sliding into the glowing heart of that oven never loses its charm.
What sets La Florentina apart is its devotion to classic Italian recipes. Their crust is thin, crisp, and just smoky enough. Gluten-free, vegan, and vegetarian options show real care for every guest.
One visit, I went for the Margherita—fresh basil and perfectly molten mozzarella. The Quattro Formaggi also deserves a spotlight, with its melty, bold flavors. If you want a spot where every pizza feels hand-crafted, La Florentina delivers the kind of slice you’ll remember.
2. Picnic Pizza
Picnic Pizza is something of a local legend. Its straightforward, no-fuss charm draws in regulars and newcomers alike. The scent of fresh pizza hits you as soon as you walk through the door, and the staff remember your face after just a few visits.
What makes Picnic Pizza stand out is its classic approach—think crispy crust, the right cheese-to-sauce ratio, and slices that hold up to a proper fold. Vegetarian and vegan options ensure no one is left out.
I once tried their veggie slice piled high with fresh peppers and mushrooms—the flavors were bright and the crust had just the right chew. If you crave an honest, satisfying slice, this is the place for your next casual stop.
3. Di Bella’s Pizza Shop
Di Bella’s Pizza Shop sits just a bit off the beaten path, but that only adds to its appeal. The interior is cozy, never too loud, and the staff treat you like an old friend. Every visit feels like a neighborhood tradition in the making.
What truly shines here is the dough—light, airy, and baked to crisp perfection. Di Bella’s keeps things straightforward, letting fresh ingredients speak for themselves. Their vegetarian options get the same level of care as every classic pie.
Order their classic cheese pizza. It’s a test of any true pizzeria, and Di Bella’s nails it: blistered cheese, tangy sauce, and a crust begging for a second slice. It’s simple, but memorable.
4. Vincenzo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante
Vincenzo’s Pizzeria & Ristorante brings a bit of old-world charm to Kingston’s Wall Street. The space feels inviting, perfect for everything from a quick slice to a full family dinner. Staff are quick to offer suggestions, and regulars swap stories across the table.
The pizza here stands out thanks to a crust that holds its own—thin, but with just enough bite. Vincenzo’s uses fresh mozzarella and a house-made sauce that has its own quiet following. The menu favors tradition, offering pizzas that taste like they’ve been refined over decades.
If you stop by, order a slice of their signature Margherita. The basil is fresh, the cheese pulls just enough, and there’s a lovely tang to the sauce. When you want a pie that balances comfort with authenticity, Vincenzo’s delivers.
5. A Slice of Italy
Walk into A Slice of Italy and you’ll notice the friendly buzz of locals who know where to find a good pie. The inside has a laid-back feel, perfect for catching up with friends while eyeing what’s coming out of the oven. It’s easy to see why people come back again and again.
What gives A Slice of Italy its charm is its commitment to traditional recipes. The dough is always fresh, with a pleasant chew and just a hint of olive oil. The menu features classic options and unique creations for every taste.
Their white pizza is a must—garlicky, creamy, and topped with just the right blend of cheeses. For anyone craving a classic slice in a relaxed setting, this spot delivers every time.
6. Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza
Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza balances casual warmth with just the right touch of elegance. The space feels inviting whether you’re grabbing lunch or lingering over dinner. Staff are always friendly, making the experience feel personal from the moment you arrive.
One thing that makes Enzo’s stand out is its attention to quality. Their dough is made fresh daily and every pizza comes out golden and crisp. The gluten-free options don’t miss a beat in flavor or texture, so everyone can join in.
The veggie pizza at Enzo’s is a regular pick for me, loaded with seasonal produce and finished with a light sprinkle of cheese. If you’re after a well-balanced pizza in a place that feels both relaxed and special, Enzo’s hits the mark.
7. King’s Pizza Restaurant
King’s Pizza Restaurant sits at the heart of Kingston, where Wall Street starts buzzing at lunchtime. The vibe is unpretentious, and orders come out hot from the oven, every slice with a generous topping. It’s easy to settle in and lose track of time over a few slices here.
King’s stands out thanks to its crust—crisp on the outside, soft inside, with a subtle flavor from their signature dough. The staff keep service smooth and friendly, even during the midday rush. There’s genuine care in every detail, from the sauce to the bubbly cheese.
The veggie pizza is worth seeking out, overflowing with peppers, onions, and mushrooms, all balanced on that flavorful base. When you want hearty, no-fuss pizza in Kingston, King’s deserves a spot on your list.
8. Tony’s Pizzeria
Tony’s Pizzeria has held its spot on Broadway for decades, and you can sense that history with every visit. The décor nods to classic pizzerias, and the steady hum of conversation adds to the authentic vibe. Stopping in here always feels a bit like stepping into the past—in the best way.
The magic is in their sauce. It’s sweet with a touch of tang, perfectly matched to their crisp-edged crust. You see families and solo diners alike digging in, everyone united over a love of pizza done right.
I always go for the classic plain slice at Tony’s. The cheese is just stretchy enough and the sauce soaks into the crust in all the right ways. If you’re after a slice of Kingston’s pizza tradition, this is the place.
9. Savona Plaza Pizza
Savona Plaza Pizza is the neighborhood go-to when you crave comfort and consistency. The open kitchen lets you watch the team work dough into those wide, golden pies. Delivery is quick, but the real fun is picking up your order and catching the waft of freshly baked crust before you leave.
This spot stands out for balancing generous portions with quality. Each slice is sturdy, yet never heavy, and the sauce has a mellow, homemade depth. It’s easy to see why locals keep coming back.
I once grabbed a veggie pizza for a casual dinner, and the blend of roasted peppers, mushrooms, and spinach was spot on. If you want pizza that’s both satisfying and reliable, Savona Plaza Pizza is a solid choice.
10. Steve’s Pizza and Deli
Steve’s Pizza and Deli is a Kingston staple that combines two cravings in one stop. The menu covers everything from subs to salads, but the pizza counter is where the action is. Locals swing by for a quick bite or a takeout box to bring home.
What makes Steve’s special is a focus on classic flavors without overcomplicating things. The dough is pillowy with just the right chew, and each slice comes out hot with a generous layer of cheese. Service is fast and always friendly—you get the sense that regulars feel like family here.
I recommend their plain cheese pie for first-timers. The balance of cheese and sauce is just right, and the crust holds up from the first bite to the last. For classic, unfussy pizza, Steve’s is a reliable pick in Kingston.
More Things to Try in Kingston, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the most popular style of pizza in Kingston, NY?
The classic New York-style slice rules in Kingston. Expect wide, thin crust that’s foldable, topped simply with sauce and mozzarella. Many places also serve Sicilian, white pizza, and specialty pies.
Are there good vegetarian and vegan pizza options in Kingston?
Yes, several pizzerias such as La Florentina and Picnic Pizza offer both vegetarian and vegan pies. You’ll find options with plenty of fresh veggies and dairy-free cheese upon request.
Which Kingston pizza spots offer gluten-free crust?
Enzo’s Ristorante & Pizza and La Florentina Restaurant are known for their gluten-free options. Always call ahead to confirm, since menus sometimes change.
Is there late-night pizza in Kingston?
Many local shops close earlier, but some like Tony’s Pizzeria and Domino’s keep ovens hot until later in the evening, perfect for a late slice.
Do most pizza places in Kingston deliver?
Most do. Savona Plaza Pizza, Picnic Pizza, and other big names offer delivery, while others focus on takeout. Check the menu or website for details.