Finding the best pizza in Highland, NY can feel like both a simple pleasure and a personal quest. The village is dotted with pizza joints, each with its own style, secret dough recipe, and loyal crowd. On my last visit, the search for a standout slice led me to unexpected corners, from a family-owned café with a staff that remembered your name, to a tiny shop where the cheese stretch was the stuff of legend. These places aren’t just about food—they’re about community, stories, and the perfect balance of sauce to crust.
As you navigate this list, you’ll find the top spots that have earned their place among locals and curious passersby alike. Whether you prefer a classic Margherita or a creative twist, you’ll get insights that come from real experience—not just a glance at the menu. Looking for a pie that’s crisp, cheesy, and worth every bite? You’ve landed in the right place. Let’s explore the flavors that give Highland its reputation for great pizza.
Where to find the best pizza in Highland, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Highland, NY:
- Pomo d’oro Pizza Cafe
- Pizza Mia
- Brennie’s Pizzeria
- Godfather’s Pizza
- Pavese’s Pizza
- Bella Amici Pizza
- Big Guy Pizza
- Ronni’s Pizzeria of Holland Ny
- Brennies Pizza
- Piccolo Fiore Restaurant & Pizzeria
1. Pomo d’oro Pizza Cafe
Pomo d’oro Pizza Cafe sits quietly on Haviland Road, but its pizza is far from shy. Stepping inside, you’ll find a warm, bustling space where the scent of fresh dough lets you know you’re in for something special. On my last visit, I was struck by the friendly chatter between the staff and regulars—it’s clear Pomo d’oro has its fans.
What makes this spot shine? Their crust is the crisp, airy kind that holds a light char, and the sauce leans rich without stealing the show. The Margherita brings out the best in their house-made mozzarella and basil, while the Veggie Pie is a local favorite, stacked high but never soggy.
Pair your pizza with their quick takeout service on a busy day, or enjoy a leisurely dinner in a lively setting. Pomo d’oro’s personality shows in every slice.
2. Pizza Mia
Pizza Mia brings a touch of classic comfort to the Highland pizza scene. This spot is roomy, inviting, and always has a stream of locals popping in for their favorites. The first time I stopped by, the aroma of baking bread and bubbling cheese pulled me in before I even looked at the menu.
The crust here is where Pizza Mia shines—thin, with a gentle chew and just enough bite. It’s topped with a bright tomato sauce that manages to taste both fresh and familiar. Their plain cheese pie is a safe bet; sometimes simple is just right.
Looking to get adventurous? Their White Pizza earns high marks, with creamy ricotta and a shower of fresh herbs. You can grab a slice to go, but slowing down for a seat is never a bad decision at Pizza Mia.
3. Brennie’s Pizzeria
Brennie’s Pizzeria is tucked into the heart of Highland, bringing a dose of classic Italian flavor to Vineyard Avenue. The place has a cozy, small-town feel that makes it easy to linger a little longer than planned. On my last visit, the owner chatted with customers from behind the counter—there’s a real sense of community here.
The pizza stands out for its hearty New York-style slices: wide, foldable, and loaded with cheese that stretches for miles. Try their Sicilian—a thick, golden crust topped with tangy sauce and a generous layer of mozzarella. It’s perfect for anyone craving a filling, comforting bite.
If you’re up for something classic, the plain cheese or veggie slices are local favorites. Each bite shows why Brennie’s is on everyone’s list for reliable, satisfying pizza in Highland.
4. Godfather’s Pizza
Godfather’s Pizza sits right on Route 299 and doesn’t mess around with frills—here, it’s all about generous portions and unfussy comfort. Walk in and you’ll find a casual atmosphere, with families and friends dropping by at every hour. My last visit was on a rainy evening, and the warm, doughy scent alone made braving the weather worth it.
This spot is known for its hearty pizzas with soft, pillowy crusts and bold, zippy sauce. Their classic Supreme is a must; loaded with fresh veggies and melty cheese, it sums up the Godfather’s experience—big flavors, simple pleasures.
If you like your pizza traditional but substantial, their cheese pie or veggie option is right on brand. Grab a slice and you’ll see why it’s a Highland mainstay.
5. Pavese’s Pizza
(845) 691-8446Call
Pavese’s Pizza has been holding down a cozy corner of Vineyard Avenue for years. This is the kind of spot you stumble into, then wonder why you waited so long to try it. On one busy Friday night, I watched a steady stream of regulars picking up orders, a clear sign of a loyal following.
What sets Pavese’s apart is its crust—thin but sturdy, baked to a perfect golden crisp, and always cut generously. The sauce has a subtle sweetness, matched perfectly by gooey cheese and fresh toppings. Their Veggie Pizza is a standout, each bite bursting with bell peppers and mushrooms that actually taste fresh.
For a true taste of Highland’s pizza scene, start with a classic cheese and work your way through the menu. Pavese’s is one of those places where even a simple slice feels special.
6. Bella Amici Pizza
(845) 834-3222Call
Bella Amici Pizza sits on US Highway 9W, delivering classic pies with a welcoming neighborhood vibe. It’s the sort of place where you walk in and instantly feel like part of the family. My favorite experience here was an impromptu dinner—the staff’s warmth landed me a great recommendation without fuss.
The pizza at Bella Amici is memorable for its balance: crisp crust, zesty sauce, and cheese layered with care. The White Pizza is a local highlight, topped with ricotta and hints of garlic that make every bite rich but never heavy.
Those after something veggie-filled should try the Primavera—it’s colorful, fresh, and always satisfying. With friendly service and consistent quality, Bella Amici keeps Highland’s pizza tradition alive and well.
7. Big Guy Pizza
(845) 691-2500Call
Big Guy Pizza sits right on Vineyard Avenue and is easy to spot, thanks to the steady stream of folks heading in and out with piping hot boxes. This spot is unfussy, with a focus on generous portions and classic flavors. My first stop here ended with a massive slice and a new appreciation for their old-school style.
Their pizza stands out for its hearty crust—thick enough for a substantial bite yet never doughy or bland. The cheese slice is a favorite, blanketed with just the right amount of sauce and gooey cheese, each ingredient playing its part.
Looking for something with a kick? The Veggie Supreme piles on fresh peppers and onions, offering texture and that local pizzeria charm. Big Guy Pizza is perfect when you need a slice that delivers on flavor and satisfaction.
8. Ronni’s Pizzeria of Holland Ny
(716) 537-9771Call
Ronni’s Pizzeria of Holland NY is nestled on Main Street, bringing a hometown feel to Highland’s pizza lineup. This spot is a true slice of small-town life, where the staff greets locals by name and the vibe is easygoing. My last visit was on a blustery afternoon, and a hot slice here felt especially comforting.
Ronni’s pizza has a distinctive crust—firm enough to hold its shape, but light enough to keep you reaching for another slice. Their cheese pie is the standard bearer: balanced sauce, bubbling cheese, and a finish that keeps regulars coming back.
If you want something a little different, try their Veggie Pizza; it’s topped fresh and always satisfying. Ronni’s offers a reliable, welcoming spot for any pizza craving in Highland.
9. Brennies Pizza
(845) 691-7213Call
Brennies Pizza on Tillson Avenue Ext is the kind of hidden spot you wish you’d discovered sooner. The mood is casual and a little nostalgic, with pizza boxes stacked behind the counter and a team that works with quiet confidence. My last visit revealed a steady flow of loyal customers—never a bad sign in a small town.
The signature here is a thick, satisfying crust that’s golden without being overly heavy. Their cheese pizza nails the classic ratio of sauce to cheese, making every bite balanced and moreish. The Veggie Pie is a standout, never stingy with toppings and always fresh.
Brennies is a go-to for a quick bite or a laid-back meal with friends. In Highland, this pizza joint stands out for its steady quality and subtle charm.
10. Piccolo Fiore Restaurant & Pizzeria
(845) 691-3700Call
Piccolo Fiore Restaurant & Pizzeria sits right on State Route 44 55, offering a cozy spot for those who like their pizza with a side of homestyle charm. The setting is graceful yet unfussy, perfect for both a casual lunch and a relaxed dinner. The first time I stopped by, I was greeted with the kind of hospitality you remember long after the meal.
Their pizza has a thin, flavorful crust and a robust sauce that brings all the toppings together. I’d recommend the Margherita for a taste of fresh basil and house cheese that’s both light and rich. Their Veggie Pizza is also a solid choice, bubbling with flavor and texture.
Piccolo Fiore stands out for its attention to detail and genuine warmth. It’s a place where classic flavors meet a touch of elegance on every plate.
More Things to Try in Highland, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Highland, NY?
Highland is home to well-known favorites like Pomo d’oro Pizza Cafe, Pizza Mia, and Brennie’s Pizzeria, each known for great pizza and friendly service.
Are there any vegetarian-friendly pizza options in Highland?
Yes, most local spots offer several vegetarian pizzas, including classic Margherita and veggie-loaded pies at places like Pomo d’oro, Bella Amici, and Piccolo Fiore.
Is there halal or kosher pizza in Highland, NY?
Most pizzerias in Highland focus on traditional toppings. For specific requirements, it’s best to call the restaurant in advance to confirm their menu options.
Do any pizzerias in Highland offer gluten-free pizza?
Some pizzerias offer gluten-free crusts. Call ahead to Pizza Mia or Pomo d’oro to ask about gluten-free options and kitchen practices.
Can I get pizza delivered in Highland?
Absolutely. Delivery is common from spots like Domino’s, Pizza Mia, and Godfather’s Pizza. Several others offer takeout for quick pick-up.
What’s a must-try pizza in Highland for a first-time visitor?
The classic Margherita or a veggie pie are always safe bets to sample Highland’s pizza style. Try the Sicilian at Brennie’s or White Pizza at Pizza Mia for something different.