Few foods inspire as much devotion as pizza. In Nanuet, NY, the quest for the perfect slice is a serious undertaking, shaped by passionate local favorites and secret recipes passed down for decades. If you’ve ever found yourself debating whether to go thin crust, classic Neapolitan, or a gooey New York slice, Nanuet has an answer. I once found myself wandering into a local shop on a rainy afternoon, drawn by the scent of bubbling cheese and fresh basil. The first bite was enough to turn an ordinary day into a small celebration.
This guide is your shortcut to the best pizza in Nanuet, NY. Whether you crave a blazing-hot pie from a classic pizzeria or want to try a hidden gem off the main drag, you’re in the right place. Expect clear reviews grounded in real visits, a little humor, and zero tolerance for bland or soggy slices. Before you know it, you’ll have a new favorite spot and perhaps a story or two of your own.
Where to find the best pizza in Nanuet, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Nanuet, NY:
- Martio’s Pizza
- Posa Posa
- Nanuet Hotel & Restaurant
- Patsy’s Pizzeria
- Nanuet Restaurant
- Franco’s Pizza
- Cacciatori Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
- Chuck E Cheese’s
1. Martio’s Pizza
Step into Martio’s Pizza and you’ll see why locals guard this spot so closely. The family-owned vibe hits you before the aroma does, blending nostalgia with the promise of a satisfying meal. I once ducked in on a busy Friday, only to end up chatting with staff who knew half their customers by name. This creates a sense of community that adds to every visit.
The pizza here leans classic, with a crust that walks the line between crispy and chewy. For a quintessential experience, go for the Sicilian slice—airy, flavorful, and always generously topped. The Margherita, dotted with fresh basil and a lively tomato sauce, brings out Martio’s attention to detail. It’s proof that the classics don’t just endure—they thrive.
2. Posa Posa
Posa Posa is one of those spots where every pizza arrives looking like it belongs in a magazine. The energy here is unmistakable—families laughing over pies and servers carrying heaping trays with practiced ease. On my last visit, the steady hum of conversation made even a solo meal feel like a lively gathering.
Posa Posa stands out for its inventive pizza choices and perfect execution. Their thin crust manages both crunch and chew, never losing balance. Try the Grandma pizza; the deep flavors of the sauce and scattering of fresh basil set it apart. If you’re after something classic, the white pizza is rich, creamy, and sure to leave a mark. Posa Posa doesn’t just serve pizza—they give it personality.
3. Nanuet Hotel & Restaurant
At first glance, Nanuet Hotel & Restaurant may look like an old-school tavern, but there’s a reason its pizza draws a crowd. This place is a local legend, a setting where I once ended up splitting pies with friends who couldn’t agree on toppings—and no one left disappointed. The warm, no-frills atmosphere means the food takes center stage.
Their pizza is known for its sturdy, golden crust and generous toppings. The plain cheese pie, which might sound simple, manages a careful balance of crisp base and gooey mozzarella. The veggie pie brims with fresh ingredients, making each slice as filling as it is flavorful. If you want a slice that captures the spirit of Nanuet, this is where to start.
4. Patsy’s Pizzeria
Patsy’s Pizzeria feels like a slice of city life, yet it’s comfortably tucked into Nanuet’s shopping district. My last visit was on a busy evening, and the open kitchen’s energy was matched only by the smell of fresh dough. Every seat holds the promise of something memorable from their wood-fired oven.
Patsy’s delivers thin, charred crusts and pure flavors that let fresh ingredients shine. The traditional Margherita pizza is a must—each bite feels both classic and vibrant, with creamy mozzarella and aromatic basil. For those with special diets, vegan and gluten-free options never feel like an afterthought. If you want a no-nonsense, New York-style pie, Patsy’s understands the assignment.
5. Nanuet Restaurant
Some places feel like a step back in time, and Nanuet Restaurant holds onto that classic charm with ease. My first visit was as part of an impromptu lunch, where their pizza set the bar high before the rest of the meal even arrived. The staff treat you like a regular from the jump, adding to the appeal.
Their pizza is well-balanced and always fresh, with a crust that stays light yet sturdy. The Mushroom & Peppers pie stands out for its use of tender vegetables and a sauce with noticeable depth. If you lean toward traditional comfort food, the plain cheese creates pure nostalgia. At Nanuet Restaurant, you get a taste of familiarity, done better than you’d expect.
6. Franco’s Pizza
Franco’s Pizza feels like the heartbeat of Nanuet’s pizza scene. This second-generation family spot combines tradition and comfort in every detail, from the faded family photos to the inviting, bustling dining room. I’ve dropped by for a quick slice before errands and ended up savoring a pie in their friendly dining area with the lunchtime crowd.
What separates Franco’s is their dedication to always-fresh ingredients and recipes with real roots. The classic Neapolitan pizza hits all the right notes—simple, light, yet completely satisfying. For something with a little more heft, try their veggie-loaded pie, featuring crisp peppers and mushrooms. At Franco’s, pizza is more than a menu item; it’s a family tradition served on every plate.
7. Cacciatori Pizza
Cacciatori Pizza doesn’t put on airs. This is the place for straightforward, no-nonsense pies that keep locals coming back. My first delivery from here was late on a cold night, and the pizza arrived piping hot, with cheese that still stretched for miles. That first bite set a high bar for comfort food in Nanuet.
Cacciatori’s standout quality lies in consistency and flavor. Their classic cheese pizza is a neighborhood favorite: a golden crust, just the right sauce-to-cheese ratio, and a hint of oregano that lingers. If you want something a bit richer, the Sicilian slices layer on extra doughy goodness without ever getting heavy. Cacciatori Pizza makes it easy to find your reliable, go-to pie.
8. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Nanuet is a familiar name, but sometimes that’s exactly what you want. The comfort of knowing your crust will be stuffed, the sauce tangy, and the cheese layered just right has its own appeal. I’ve had my share of quick takeout nights here, and the promise of a reliable pizza never falls short.
What sets this location apart is consistency and that signature Pizza Hut flavor profile. The Original Stuffed Crust always gets top marks, with its melty cheese edge and pillowy base. The Veggie Lovers keeps things colorful and filling. When you want a pizza that delivers nostalgia and predictability in every slice, Pizza Hut stands ready in Nanuet.
9. BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse
BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse isn’t your average pizza spot. The vibe is lively, with a menu as broad as the dining room itself. My go-to order here is always deep dish pizza, lined with bubbling cheese and packed with toppings—even on a busy night, the pies come out hot and inviting.
BJ’s stands out for its California twist on Chicago-style deep dish. The Vegetarian Deep Dish leans into freshness, with layers of chunky tomatoes and tender veggies. If you’re avoiding gluten, their gluten-free crust doesn’t skimp on flavor or texture. BJ’s makes it easy to try something classic while exploring bolder options, all under one roof.
10. Chuck E Cheese’s
Chuck E Cheese’s in Nanuet isn’t just about the games and the music; the pizza actually holds its own. Every visit here means laughter in the air and families sharing pies over friendly competition. I remember splitting slices while keeping an eye on the prize tickets, and being pleasantly surprised by how well the pizza rounded out the experience.
It’s the cheesy, foldable slices that steal the show, especially for kids who need energy for arcade fun. The classic cheese and veggie pizzas deliver a satisfying bite with a simple, approachable flavor. Chuck E Cheese’s blends the nostalgia of childhood celebrations with pizza that, while humble, serves its purpose—bringing everyone together at the table.
More Things to Try in Nanuet, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Nanuet, NY?
Some of Nanuet’s most popular pizza spots include Martio’s Pizza, Posa Posa, Nanuet Hotel & Restaurant, and Patsy’s Pizzeria. Each has its loyal following and a different style to satisfy any craving.
Is there a place for gluten-free or vegan pizza in Nanuet?
Yes, places like Patsy’s Pizzeria and BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse offer gluten-free and vegan pizza options. This makes it easy to find something whether you have dietary restrictions or just want to try something new.
Where can I find classic New York-style pizza in Nanuet?
Martio’s Pizza and Patsy’s Pizzeria are known for serving up classic New York-style pies, complete with thin crusts and generous, gooey cheese.
Which spots are best for families or large groups?
Chuck E Cheese’s is perfect for families, thanks to its kid-friendly setting and playful atmosphere. Franco’s Pizza and BJ’s Restaurant & Brewhouse also have spacious seating and group-friendly menus.
Can I get pizza delivered in Nanuet?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias in Nanuet, including Cacciatori Pizza, Pizza Hut, and Franco’s Pizza, offer delivery for those nights when leaving home sounds like too much effort.
Are there any vegetarian-friendly options?
Plenty. Nearly every pizzeria on this list offers vegetarian pizzas, with fresh veggie toppings or cheese-only pies. Some even provide unique specialty combinations that go beyond standard fare.