The search for the best pizza in Larchmont, NY is a pursuit that invites curiosity, craving, and a bit of nostalgia. Whether you’re celebrating a win, catching up with friends, or just escaping another night of cooking, there’s something about a perfectly blistered crust and well-balanced sauce that stirs up anticipation. I once spent an entire afternoon wandering Palmer Avenue in pursuit of that one slice promised by a local, and found more than a few standout spots—all with stories and flavors baked into every bite.
You don’t have to settle for good enough when so many pizzerias here turn pizza-making into an art. This guide draws on hours of sampling, neighborhood debates, and a local’s eye for what makes a pie memorable. Whether you’re devoted to a classic Margherita or lean toward out-of-the-box toppings, you’ll find honest opinions, sharp descriptions, and zero fluff. The real challenge? Narrowing it down to just one favorite.
Where to find the best pizza in Larchmont, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Larchmont, NY:
- Nicky’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
- Villa Maria Pizza
- Leonardo’s Pizzeria
- Billy & Pete’s Social
- Augie’s Restaurant
- Nova Pizzabar
- Polpettina
- Homemade Pizza Co
- Giovanni Manna
- Giordano’s
1. Nicky’s Pizzeria & Restaurant
Nicky’s Pizzeria & Restaurant remains a favorite for authentic, crowd-pleasing pizza with a local charm. Tucked on Chatsworth Avenue, Nicky’s feels welcoming from the first step inside. The staff remembers faces, and slices arrive hot and generously topped.
My first visit ran on a friend’s recommendation, and since then, I’ve found myself returning for the classic cheese pizza—both rich and perfectly balanced with a hearty sauce. Their veggie pie is crisp around the edges and packed with flavor, ideal for those craving something lighter.
Nicky’s also shines with their grandma slice, its square shape and robust tomato sauce offering a nice contrast to traditional options. For dependable, delicious pizza right in Larchmont, Nicky’s checks every box.
2. Villa Maria Pizza
Villa Maria Pizza sits just steps from the train station, making it a perfect stop for commuters and locals looking for classic New York-style pizza done right. The aroma inside hints at dough that gets true respect—soft inside with that crucial outer crunch. On my last visit, the line started at the door, but the team moved with efficiency and warmth, never rushing anyone’s choices.
The plain slice is a standout, with a thin but sturdy crust and a sauce that’s both tangy and bright. If you want a little more, their white pizza comes generously dotted with ricotta and melts just right. I always leave wishing I had room for one more slice.
Villa Maria knows how to keep pizza straightforward and satisfying, offering slices that never disappoint after a busy day.
3. Leonardo’s Pizzeria
Leonardo’s Pizzeria delivers generous, satisfying slices in the heart of Larchmont. The space is cozy, creating the sort of spot where you can slow down and savor a slice straight from the oven. My go-to here is their classic Margherita pizza—fresh basil layered over gooey mozzarella, with a sauce that tastes like summer tomatoes.
The crust is sturdy yet light, perfect for folding, which I can never resist. If you’re in the mood for something richer, the vegetarian pizza bursts with color and flavor, showing off Leonardo’s knack for thoughtful toppings. Service feels unhurried in the best way, and you get a sense the staff enjoys what they do.
Leonardo’s is where I turn when I want the kind of pizza that competes with memory itself.
4. Billy & Pete’s Social
Billy & Pete’s Social feels like the kind of place where everyone can relax and share a meal. You’ll notice right away their wood-fired pizzas carry a touch of creativity that’s rare in Larchmont. On my recent visit, the lively setting made even weeknights feel celebratory, with families and friends tucking into fresh pies at big tables.
Don’t skip their margherita pizza—the charred crust and creamy mozzarella mingle with basil in every bite. The veggie special shows off a thoughtful blend of flavors and seasonal toppings. Here, the toppings are chosen for how they play together, not just for show.
Billy & Pete’s Social keeps pizza imaginative without losing sight of tradition, making each visit something to look forward to.
5. Augie’s Restaurant
Augie’s Restaurant draws regulars with a menu that celebrates both tradition and comfort. The dining room buzzes with families, and the service is steady, never rushed. Once, sharing pizza with friends here, I found myself reaching for a second slice before realizing I hadn’t even sampled the rest of my meal.
The thin-crust cheese pizza is the showstopper—golden edges, stretchy mozzarella, and a robust tomato sauce. For a heartier option, the vegetable pie shines with perfectly roasted toppings and a light, crispy base.
Portions are generous, which makes Augie’s a great choice for groups. The atmosphere is inviting, and the pizza captures all that’s good about honest Italian cooking right in Larchmont.
6. Nova Pizzabar
Nova Pizzabar brings a fresh energy to the Larchmont pizza scene, merging classic technique with modern flair. The space has a crisp, inviting look, making it just as right for a quick lunch as a low-key dinner. It’s the sort of spot where the aroma of baking dough draws you in before the menu even arrives.
My pick here is the Margherita pizza, which arrives with a perfectly pillowy crust and a sauce that hums with real tomato flavor. The vegetable pizza has bright, fresh produce, and you can taste the kitchen’s attention to quality in every bite.
Nova sets itself apart with both its welcoming vibe and its use of fresh ingredients, making every slice worth the detour.
7. Polpettina
Polpettina brings an inventive twist to pizza in Larchmont, balancing creativity with classic comfort. The space is lively yet cozy, and every visit feels like joining a neighborhood tradition. Last time, I found myself wishing I could taste every pie coming from the oven—each looked more tempting than the last.
The classic Margherita is always a crowd-pleaser, but the real surprise for me was the roasted vegetable pizza. The toppings are thoughtfully arranged and roasted, highlighting every flavor without weighing things down.
Polpettina manages to blend a playful menu with thoughtful execution. If you want pizza that surprises without straying from what you love, this spot is a must-try.
8. Homemade Pizza Co
(914) 833-8338Call
Homemade Pizza Co lives up to its name by delivering pizza that feels personal and genuine. The moment you walk in, the scent of fresh dough lets you know you’re in for something a bit different. On my first visit, the relaxed, no-fuss setup made the experience delightfully straightforward.
Their classic thin crust stands out—slightly crisp, easy to fold, and brimming with just the right amount of cheese and sauce. I still remember savoring a slice topped with roasted vegetables, each bite feeling balanced and comforting.
Homemade Pizza Co brings a homemade touch to every pie, making it easy to see why so many locals have their favorites here. It’s pizza with a personal twist, served without any pretense.
9. Giovanni Manna
(914) 438-1065Call
Giovanni Manna is tucked away on Chatsworth Avenue, but word travels fast about the quality of their pizza. The place radiates a welcoming, family-run vibe—the kind where you’ll spot regulars picking up their usual orders. When I first tried the pizza here, it was on a rainy afternoon, and the mood instantly improved with that first bite.
The classic cheese pizza is everything a slice should be: crisp on the outside, soft in the middle, and topped with a rich, flavorful sauce. For something different, the vegetarian pie is loaded with fresh, colorful toppings that never weigh down the crust.
Giovanni Manna is the spot for those who appreciate unfussy, well-made pizza that always delivers on taste and comfort.
10. Giordano’s
(914) 478-7874Call
Giordano’s is one of those old-school gems where family recipes anchor the menu and every visit feels like coming home. The booth seating and framed photos speak to decades of happy gatherings. The last time I stopped by, the friendly buzz in the dining room was matched by the steady flow of piping-hot pies.
The plain cheese pizza gets the fundamentals just right—stretchy mozzarella, zesty sauce, and a crust that holds it all without getting soggy. If you want to switch it up, the vegetable pizza impresses with fresh toppings and a nice balance between sauce and cheese.
Giordano’s stands out for its straightforward approach and flavors that keep regulars coming back generation after generation.
More Things to Try in Larchmont, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the top pizza places in Larchmont, NY?
Some favorites include Nicky’s Pizzeria & Restaurant, Villa Maria Pizza, Leonardo’s Pizzeria, and Polpettina. Each spot brings something different—classic slices, inventive toppings, or cozy atmospheres.
Where can I find vegetarian pizza options in Larchmont?
Most pizzerias in Larchmont, such as Nicky’s, Villa Maria, and Polpettina, offer vegetarian-friendly pizzas including veggie pies and classic Margherita.
Does Larchmont have wood-fired pizza spots?
Yes. Billy & Pete’s Social is popular for its wood-fired pizzas that feature beautifully charred crusts and fresh ingredients.
Which pizza place is best for families or groups?
Augie’s Restaurant and Giordano’s both offer spacious seating and crowd-pleasing menu options, perfect for sharing with family and friends.
Can I get gluten-free pizza in Larchmont?
Many pizzerias offer a gluten-free crust option, though it’s always best to call ahead to confirm availability and details.
Are there pizza spots near the Larchmont train station?
Absolutely. Villa Maria Pizza is just steps from the station, making it an ideal stop for commuters needing a quick, hot slice.