Hunting for the best pizza in Modesto is not for the indecisive. You can’t just wander downtown and hope for the perfect slice to fall in your lap. The city hides gems where the crust is crisp, the sauce flavorful, and the cheese, let’s say, generous. On my last visit, I bit into a slice so good it had me plotting my next trip before I’d finished chewing. Modesto doesn’t just feed you; it raises the bar for what you expect from pizza.
If you’re serious about your next pizza night, you’re in the right place. This guide isn’t peppered with wild claims or tired chains. Instead, it brings you the full spread—from local family spots to the indispensable big names—with an honest, clear-eyed look at what each offers. The secret to pizza satisfaction in Modesto is knowing where to look. Let’s dig in to the city’s richest pies and crustiest stories.
Where to find the best pizza in Modesto, CA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Modesto, CA:
- Redwood Cafe
- Michael’s Pizza Bar and Grill
- Nizario’s Pizza & Grill
- Mountain Mike’s
- Mountain Mike’s
- Milano Pizza
- Pizza Hut
- Mountain Mike’s
- Round Table Pizza
- Mountain Mike’s
1. Redwood Cafe
Redwood Cafe proves that pizza can be both refined and comforting. The space balances classy flourishes with the warmth you want in a local eatery. My first bite of their Margherita felt almost too good for its price—fresh basil and mozzarella on perfectly blistered crust.
What sets Redwood Cafe apart is its ambition. The menu leans into California flavors, so expect inventive toppings and garden-fresh vegetables. You can pair your pizza with an ever-changing selection of wines, which is a rare treat in Modesto.
Don’t miss the Wild Mushroom Pizza. It’s earthy, rich, and shows off the cafe’s knack for quality ingredients. For something classic, you can’t go wrong with their traditional pepperoni—simple, but never boring.
2. Michael’s Pizza Bar and Grill
Michael’s Pizza Bar and Grill has that easygoing neighborhood spirit that’s hard to fake. The moment you walk in, delicious aromas and the buzz of happy regulars tell you you’ve found something real. During my last lunch stop here, the staff remembered my name—and my favorite pizza.
This spot keeps things classic without being dull. The crust strikes a sweet spot: thick enough to hold hearty toppings but never doughy. Locals swear by the house special, a loaded veggie pizza bursting with color and crunch. You’ll find the cheese melts into every bite, binding everything together.
Try the BBQ Chicken Pizza for something memorable. The sauce is tangy, the toppings generous, and the whole is as comforting as pizza gets in Modesto. It’s simple, it’s bold, and it works.
3. Nizario’s Pizza & Grill
Nizario’s Pizza & Grill operates at the crossroads of comfort and flavor. The place has a casual, lively vibe, perfect for groups or quick solo meals. On my last visit, a slice of their veggie pizza delivered a welcome punch of flavor—you taste every ingredient.
The dough here is a real highlight. It’s chewy, sturdy, and always freshly made. Their approach focuses on generous toppings and a well-balanced sauce that never overwhelms. Every pizza guarantees hearty portions and bold, satisfying flavors.
Order the Garden Delight Pizza if you want to taste Modesto produce at its best. The combination of colorful veggies on a perfectly baked crust feels fresh and homemade. Nizario’s makes pizza that’s reliably delicious, every single time.
4. Mountain Mike’s
Mountain Mike’s has a certain charm that pulls in everyone from families to hungry college students. You can’t walk past their kitchen without catching the scent of baking dough and melted cheese. My most memorable visit included a pizza night with friends—everyone agreed the crust has a golden crunch that’s hard to beat.
Fans love Mountain Mike’s for its consistent quality. The pizza comes loaded with toppings, and every bite packs plenty of flavor. Their legendary pepperoni, cupped and crisped at the edges, is a must-try. It’s the kind of pizza that begs you to grab a second slice.
Order the Everest if you’re in the mood for a feast. Piled high with veggies and cheese, it shows off why this spot is a Modesto favorite.
5. Mountain Mike’s
Mountain Mike’s on Yosemite Blvd brings the same rustic energy that’s now synonymous with the brand. You know what to expect here: plenty of seating, a steady stream of regulars, and that unmistakable pizza aroma you can’t fake. My personal go-to is a veggie pizza shared over laughter with friends—their toppings are always crisp and colorful.
This location stands out for its welcoming staff and fast service, even on busy weekends. The dough stays light and crunchy, with a perfect ratio of sauce to cheese. You’ll notice each pizza looks as good as it tastes.
Sample the Garlic Tuscan pizza if you want something a little different. Rich in flavor and texture, it represents what Mountain Mike’s does best: sharing good pizza moments with Modesto locals.
6. Milano Pizza
Milano Pizza feels like the kind of local spot you stumble into once and return to for years. There’s an easy charm to the place, with friendly faces behind the counter and a menu that straddles pizza classics with Mediterranean influences. On my last visit, I tried a veggie pie that had the perfect crunch and plenty of bright, zesty flavor.
The dough here is made fresh and rolled just right, so every slice stays crisp from start to finish. Milano’s doesn’t skimp on toppings or flavor, and fans swear by their signature red sauce—a little bold, a touch sweet.
Order the Greek Pizza if you want something different. Topped with feta and olives, it’s a delicious bridge between Modesto and the Mediterranean.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut on Orangeburg Ave has its own flavor of nostalgia. Whether you’re craving a quick solo dinner or grabbing a pie for the whole family, it’s reliable and easy. My last visit was a comfort-food rescue on a late Friday night—the buttery scent of their stuffed crust was enough to lift my spirits.
This branch stands out for quick, friendly service and a spotless dining space. The pizza is as you remember: gooey cheese, that iconic crust, and plenty of craveable options. If you want something hearty, the Veggie Lover’s always arrives packed with toppings and flavor.
Try the Original Stuffed Crust if you want classic Pizza Hut satisfaction. One bite and you’ll remember exactly why this chain still has loyal local fans.
8. Mountain Mike’s
Mountain Mike’s on E Hatch Rd brings bold pizza options to Modesto’s south side. Here, the vibe is friendly and relaxed, perfect for a low-key lunchtime break or a big group dinner. I last dropped in after a long day, and the staff greeted me with a smile and a hot, fresh pie.
This location takes pride in its crisp edges and generous layers of cheese. The crust runs golden and just the right amount of chewy, making each slice feel like a special treat. There’s plenty of seating, and large orders are handled with speed.
Get the Mount Veggiemore for a well-loaded, classic option. It’s brimming with fresh produce, capturing Mountain Mike’s local approach and crowd-pleasing style.
9. Round Table Pizza
Round Table Pizza on Orangeburg Ave earns loyalty with its inviting space and signature pies. It’s a cornerstone for family gatherings, thanks to plenty of seating and a laid-back atmosphere. My last pizza night here ended with everyone grabbing an extra slice, insisting it was “the best crust yet.”
This spot is known for savory sauces and a dough that’s always fresh. The toppings are stacked high and flavors stay balanced, no matter what you pick. There’s care in every layer, from the cheese to the crisp veggies.
Try the Guinevere’s Garden Delight; it’s loaded with garden-grown produce and bright flavors, showing off the kitchen’s knack for freshness and variety.
10. Mountain Mike’s
Mountain Mike’s on E Orangeburg Ave feels like the gathering place for Modesto pizza fans who want hearty slices and a relaxed setting. The room is often filled with laughter, especially on busy weekends. During one lively night, my pizza arrived hot and so packed with toppings it was hard to see the cheese.
This spot is consistent—crunchy on the edges, soft in the middle. The pepperoni is famous for its crispy curls and just-spicy bite. If you’re in a rush, their efficient team makes pickup quick and easy. You know exactly what you’re getting every time.
Order the Snowy Alps pizza for something rich and flavorful. With its blend of fresh veggies and a generous layer of mozzarella, it’s perfect for fans of cheesy, satisfying pies.
More Things to Try in Modesto, CA
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Modesto?
Top choices include Redwood Cafe, Mountain Mike’s, Michael’s Pizza Bar and Grill, and Round Table Pizza. Each offers its own twist—from classic pepperoni to inventive veggie pies.
Are there vegetarian or gluten-free pizza options in Modesto?
Yes, several spots like Redwood Cafe and Milano Pizza offer both vegetarian and gluten-free choices. Most chains in the area also accommodate these needs—just ask when you order.
Which Modesto pizzerias offer delivery or takeout?
Almost all the major pizza spots—such as Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, and Mountain Mike’s—offer delivery, takeout, or curbside pickup. Local favorites like Michael’s Pizza Bar and Grill also provide convenient options.
Where can I find the best family-friendly pizza restaurants?
Chuck E. Cheese, Mountain Mike’s, and John’s Incredible Pizza are popular with families thanks to roomy tables and fun atmospheres, making them ideal for gatherings of all ages.
What pizza places in Modesto have unique or specialty pizzas?
Redwood Cafe and Milano Pizza both serve specialty pies you won’t find anywhere else in town, with unique toppings and imaginative combinations.