Hunting for the best pizza in Greenwood, IN can feel like a quest. The choices can be dizzying. Is there room for New York-style, or does a classic deep-dish reign supreme? Greenwood’s pizza scene isn’t just about gooey cheese and crackling crust. It’s a mix of old favorites and new spots that have quietly convinced locals to pick up the phone—or better yet, show up in person.
One evening I set out with friends to sample pies across town. We each chose a different spot from the long list, and a friendly competition began. Some gravitated toward a family-run joint with pillowy crust, while others argued the foldable slices from a hidden corner shop had the most flavor. That night, each bite had its own character, its own story. If you want to sort out your own favorite, this list covers the must-know pizza stops in Greenwood—each with something unique to offer hungry locals and first-timers alike.
1. Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza
Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza does pizza a little differently. You notice the creativity the second you walk in. Their menu reads like a love letter to inventiveness, with toppings you might not expect but will remember long after your visit.
The “Slaughterhouse Five” is a local legend, stacking five meats on a crisp, hand-tossed crust. Vegetarians get real options here, too, not just an afterthought. If you’re adventurous, try the Thai Chicken or the surprisingly balanced Greek option.
Jockamo makes pizza that sparks conversation. My group shared slices and opinions. Every bite led to lively debate about which specialty pizza won the prize. For a meal that invites both comfort and surprise, this spot stands tall in Greenwood’s lineup.
2. Arni’s
Arni’s sits comfortably in Greenwood’s pizza scene, with a loyal crowd that appreciates tradition and friendly service. This is the place where families gather for relaxed dinners and memories grow slice by slice. The menu keeps things classic but never boring.
I once spent an entire afternoon here with friends, losing track of time as empty platters turned into conversations. Their famous “Arni’s Junior Salad” comes loaded and fresh, great as a starter. For pizza, the “Arni’s Deluxe” steals the show—thick with cheese, crisped just right, and everything works in harmony.
Portion sizes encourage sharing and lingering a while. If you like your pizza with a side of nostalgia and warmth, Arni’s fills that role beautifully in Greenwood.
3. Main Street Grille
Main Street Grille is the kind of spot where everyone seems to find their comfort zone. The atmosphere feels more like a friend’s dining room than a typical pizza place, and the menu caters to that relaxed vibe—pizza is just the beginning here.
On my last visit, a group of us ordered several pies, with the “Four Cheese” quickly disappearing before the rest hit the table. Their veggie pizza, loaded with fresh peppers and mushrooms, made even the meat-lovers at our table take notice. Each crust comes out perfectly balanced: chewy, yet just crisp enough.
If you’re looking for a pizza that doesn’t skimp on toppings or skip on flavor, Main Street Grille earns its local reputation. It’s the place for pizza-lovers who want both variety and quality in every slice.
4. South Of Chicago Pizza & Italian Beef
South Of Chicago Pizza & Italian Beef brings a slice of the Windy City right to Greenwood. If you crave classic deep dish, there’s no better stop. The layered cheese and chunky tomato sauce are bold without being overwhelming, each bite reflecting the spirit of Chicago.
On one chilly evening, I tucked into a thick slice with friends and quickly understood its draw. Don’t let the name fool you—they also do a reliably crisp thin crust that vanishes fast from the plate. The veggie options are bursting with flavor, too, so no one feels left out.
Try their signature deep dish for a real city-style experience. It’s the kind of meal that holds the table’s attention until every last piece disappears.
5. Chicago’s Pizza
Chicago’s Pizza has quietly built up a reputation for hearty, crowd-pleasing pies that never skimp on the essentials. The sauce here stands out—bright, balanced, and always layered generously. Each pizza is hefty with toppings but still manages to keep its crust crisp underneath.
During a family lunch, our table split between the thin crust veggie and a thick, classic cheese. Both had their moments, but everyone agreed: the crust had the perfect bite. You can tell these recipes have been tuned over years of neighborhood service.
If you want a pizza designed for sharing, Chicago’s Pizza delivers every time. Try a big specialty pie, or keep it simple with just cheese and sauce—their quality shines through either way.
6. Chicago’s Pizza With A Twist
Chicago’s Pizza With A Twist draws in crowds with its bold spin on tradition. This place uniquely blends classic pizza with inventive flavors inspired by Indian cuisine. The results are anything but ordinary, turning expectations on their head slice by slice.
The menu features a range of vegan, gluten-free, and classic options, making group dinners a breeze. My last visit featured a Paneer Tikka Pizza that changed my mind about what pizza could be. The mix of spices and fresh toppings kept things lively—which is half the fun.
If you’re ready to break out of the usual pizza routine, start here. The specialty pies deliver plenty of flavor, and you can taste both freshness and creativity in every bite.
7. Bob’s Tu Your Door Pizza
Bob’s Tu Your Door Pizza has been a Greenwood staple since the 1960s. This is the spot you call when hunger demands something classic and understated. Their crust has a certain homespun charm—soft, with just the right crisp on the edges.
I first tried Bob’s on a stormy night, drawn in by the promise of free delivery. Their veggie pizza landed at my door piping hot, loaded with generous toppings and gooey cheese. It tasted like tradition, minus the fuss.
The menu leans on crowd-pleasers, so try a classic cheese or pile on your favorites for custom comfort. When you crave pizza that feels welcoming, Bob’s is a Greenwood go-to.
8. Luca Pizza Di Roma
Luca Pizza Di Roma channels the spirit of an Italian pizzeria, right in the heart of Greenwood. This spot stands out for its fast service and slices that never disappoint. The shop’s counter display always tempts with fresh options, so it’s easy to see why locals stop in for a quick bite.
Once, after a long hike, I grabbed a slice of their Margherita. The thin, chewy crust and bright tomato sauce reminded me of a side street café in Rome. Each slice feels like simple, honest comfort food.
If you’re looking for an easy lunch or dinner, choose any classic slice. Quality ingredients come through in every bite, and you never have to wait long for satisfaction.
9. Greek’s Pizzeria
Greek’s Pizzeria brings something unique to the Greenwood scene, blending classic American pizza traditions with a Mediterranean touch. Their pizzas boast a golden, flaky crust and a taste that sets them apart from the basics. Every pizza looks like it was made to be shared around a crowded table.
My evening at Greek’s started with their famous breadsticks—soft inside, crisp outside, and perfect for dipping. The “Greek’s Special” pizza, loaded with fresh veggies and a zesty sauce, became an easy favorite. Every bite proved their toppings are always fresh and generously layered.
If you’re after a pizza with bold flavor and plenty of character, Greek’s Pizzeria gives you more than the standard fare. It’s a great pick when you want both tradition and a little something extra.
10. Luca Pizza
Luca Pizza quietly delivers consistent, crowd-pleasing pies in Greenwood. It’s a spot where locals stop by for a quick lunch or a familiar dinner, knowing exactly what to expect. The speedy service and friendly faces keep the dining room lively throughout the day.
During a solo lunch break, I tried their veggie slice—chewy crust with just the right touch of olive oil, piled high with crisp peppers and mushrooms. It had that simple, no-nonsense flavor you crave when you want comfort without any frills.
Stick with classic combos or customize your own. Either way, every slice at Luca Pizza arrives hot, satisfying, and true to what pizza in Greenwood should be.
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza are popular in Greenwood, IN?
Greenwood offers everything from classic hand-tossed and deep-dish to thin crust and specialty veggie pies. Each spot adds its own twist, so you’ll find both traditional and creative options.
Are there vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Greenwood?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias serve vegan and vegetarian choices, loaded with fresh veggies, dairy-free cheese, and unique sauces. Ask about gluten-free versions as well.
Which pizza place is good for families?
Places like Arni’s and Main Street Grille have roomy seating, relaxed vibes, and shareable pies that keep everyone happy.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Greenwood?
Yes. Several pizzerias—including Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza and Chicago’s Pizza With A Twist—offer gluten-free crust alongside their regular menu.
Which pizza joints deliver in Greenwood?
Most local spots and chains offer delivery. Bob’s Tu Your Door Pizza is known for reliable service, and many others have easy online ordering for delivery or takeout.
Where can I get pizza by the slice?
Luca Pizza Di Roma and some others serve ready-to-go slices, making lunch or a quick dinner convenient.