Finding great pizza in Stillwater, MN is a bit like exploring a new playlist—you might know the hits, but the real joy is discovering those unexpected favorites. I remember my own hunt for a top-tier slice here, weaving through brick-lined streets as the air hinted at garlic and bubbling cheese. Each spot, from the historic mainstays to the hangouts by the river, had its own character and surprises.
If you’re searching for the best pizza in Stillwater, you’re in luck. This town is home to everything from classic thin crusts to bubbling pies straight from wood-fired ovens. You’ll find bold flavors, laid-back atmospheres, and spots perfect for both casual bites and gatherings with friends. Curious about where to start? Stick around as I guide you through Stillwater’s most talked-about pizza spots, one delicious stop at a time.
1. Victoriano’s Pizza
Victoriano’s Pizza sits right in the heart of Main Street, serving the kind of authentic New York-style pizza that makes locals proud. My first visit was on a crisp evening, grabbing a hot slice outside while people watched the boats along the St. Croix. The crust was thin, chewy, and had that perfect fold—exactly how a city slice should be.
What really sets Victoriano’s apart is the obvious attention to detail. They don’t load on unnecessary toppings; it’s about quality over flash. I’d recommend the classic cheese or pepperoni—the balance of gooey cheese, tangy sauce, and crisp edges is tough to beat.
Vegetarian and gluten-free options make this spot easy for groups, too. Drop by for a quick slice, or linger over a whole pie on the patio.
2. Quickfire Pizza
Quickfire Pizza is the spot where the energy of Main Street meets a craving for something fresh. Walking in, I noticed the open kitchen and the speed of service—my pizza hit the table before I’d finished making up my mind about sides. Their secret? Wood-fired ovens that turn dough into crispy, blistered perfection in minutes.
Quickfire stands out for its build-your-own pizza experience. You can pile on classic or creative toppings, but I gravitate toward the Margherita. The fresh basil, robust sauce, and creamy mozzarella work together in all the right ways.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options make it a top pick for nearly any group. If you’re in a hurry but still want real flavor, Quickfire delivers in every sense.
3. Grand Pizza
Grand Pizza has a hometown vibe that puts you at ease as soon as you walk in. On my last visit, the smell of fresh dough hung in the air and old friends traded stories in the booth behind me. If you like a neighborhood spot where they get your order right every time, this is it.
What separates Grand Pizza is their generous, classic approach. The crust is hearty, the toppings are always fresh, and they don’t skimp on cheese. My go-to order is the Supreme—the blend of veggies and cheese over a golden, chewy crust is hard to resist.
With lunch, dinner, delivery, and takeout options, Grand Pizza makes enjoying a quality local pie simple no matter how busy the day gets.
4. Carbone’s Pizzeria
Carbone’s Pizzeria has a local legacy and a cozy dining room that’s perfect for family meals or laid-back dinners with friends. I first discovered their menu after a snowy Minnesota afternoon—nothing beats warming up with a fresh pie from this Stillwater staple.
Carbone’s stands out for their perfectly crisp, thin crust pizzas that come loaded with classic toppings. Every bite is balanced, not greasy, and you can taste the care in the house-made sauce and dough.
I’d recommend their Veggie pizza if you want a bit of everything, or the classic cheese if you enjoy simplicity done right. With options for lunch, dinner, delivery, and takeout, Carbone’s makes having quality pizza easy whenever the craving hits.
5. Melt Pizza Company
Melt Pizza Company brings a sense of adventure to downtown Stillwater. The first time I bit into one of their slices, I was taken by the contrast between the chewy crust and the fresh, bright toppings. The name promises gooey cheese, and they deliver without overdoing it—everything tastes in perfect balance.
Melt Pizza Company stands out with inventive flavors and quality ingredients. Each pizza feels thoughtfully assembled rather than mass-produced. If you’re up for something bold, try their specialty pies featuring roasted veggies or unique sauces. It’s the kind of place where you find new favorites you never saw coming.
Melt is all about quality and creativity, so expect surprises in every visit. Grab a seat and let their menu lead the way.
6. Gio’s Stillwater
Gio’s Stillwater feels like a hidden find on Main Street, with a menu packed with local flavor. My first visit was for an early brunch, and I was surprised to find pizza served alongside breakfast classics. Everything here leans fresh and straightforward, with produce sourced from nearby farms.
What makes Gio’s stand out is the use of local ingredients and an inviting, come-as-you-are vibe. Their pizza crust strikes a great balance—tender but sturdy, with just enough chew. I recommend trying a veggie-loaded pizza, which spotlights the season’s best.
If you’re searching for a laid-back spot that delivers both quality and comfort, Gio’s is a reliable pick. You’ll come for the pizza and stay for the friendly atmosphere.
7. Papa Johns Pizza
Papa Johns in Stillwater is where you go when you crave comfort and consistency. I’ve stopped in after a busy week, knowing exactly what to expect: warm, soft crust, plenty of cheese, and a tangy-sweet signature sauce. The storefront is easy to find, and the staff always keep things moving for quick carryout or delivery.
Papa Johns stands out with its commitment to quality basics—from the fresh dough to the garden-style toppings. Their pizza has a familiar flavor that’s hard not to love.
If you’re feeling classic, order the Garden Fresh or Cheese pizza for a hit of nostalgia done right. The menu covers all the bases, making this a steady bet for gatherings or a quiet night in.
8. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s in Stillwater is a go-to when nothing but classic, fast pizza will do. I’ve posted up here for late-night study sessions and last-minute dinners—the service is quick, and the menu never lets you down. There’s satisfaction in unboxing that familiar blue package, the aroma of melted cheese filling the room.
This Domino’s stands out for its range of crusts, from crisp Hand Tossed to hearty Handmade Pan. The quality is reliable every time, making it a favorite for larger gatherings when you need something everyone will eat. If you’re indecisive, try the Parmesan Stuffed Crust pizza—it’s rich, comforting, and packed with flavor in every slice.
With lunch and dinner options plus great value deals, Domino’s makes it easy to please everyone without a fuss.
9. The Harbor
+1 651-430-3224
The Harbor on North Hill is the neighborhood gathering spot you stumble across and never forget. My first time here, laughter from the dart league mixed with the smell of bubbling pizza and set an instantly relaxed mood. The staff treat you like a regular, even if it’s your first visit.
The Harbor stands out for its warm, inviting vibe and pizzas that deliver simple, satisfying flavor every time. These are comfort pies: golden crust, plenty of cheese, and just enough sauce to keep it interesting.
If you want the local experience, order a classic cheese or veggie pizza and soak up the atmosphere. It’s the perfect spot for a casual meal after a day roaming Stillwater’s hills.
10. Pizza Man
Pizza Man in Stillwater is where I go when I want comfort food that hits the spot every single time. Tucked in Oak Park Plaza, it has that classic pizzeria charm—a place that smells like melted cheese and fresh dough the moment you walk in. You don’t just grab a pizza here; you get a slice of local, no-nonsense tradition.
Pizza Man stands out for its big portions and crisp, golden crust. Every pizza comes piled high with toppings, yet somehow, it never turns soggy. Their sauce is tangy and bold, creating the kind of slice that’s hard to put down.
Try their Veggie Deluxe or the simple Cheese pizza—both give you a perfect showcase of what makes Pizza Man a beloved staple in Stillwater.
Frequently Asked Questions
Where can I find the best pizza in Stillwater, MN?
You’ll find great slices at places like Victoriano’s Pizza, Melt Pizza Company, and Grand Pizza. Each offers a unique style, from classic New York thin crust to creative local favorites.
Which pizzerias in Stillwater offer gluten-free or vegetarian options?
Quickfire Pizza, Melt Pizza Company, and Victoriano’s Pizza have gluten-free and vegetarian pizzas. Most local spots are happy to work with dietary needs—just ask when you order.
Do any Stillwater pizza restaurants deliver?
Yes, chains like Domino’s, Papa Johns, and Pizza Hut deliver, as do several locals. Check with each spot—they often offer takeout and delivery direct from their websites or third-party apps.
Are there any pizzerias with outdoor seating in Stillwater?
Victoriano’s Pizza has a patio, and Melt Pizza Company sometimes offers outdoor seating depending on the season. Many downtown spots have outdoor tables when the weather’s nice.
What’s the most popular pizza style in Stillwater?
New York-style thin crust is a big draw, but you’ll also find pan pizzas and wood-fired pies throughout town. Most pizzerias offer both traditional and artisan options to suit different tastes.