Best Pizza in Voorheesville, NY

No small town wears its pizza pride like Voorheesville. Whether you love a classic New York slice, crave a deep-dish detour, or need the right cheesy balance for your next Friday night, this village has a spot that delivers more than just lunch. Pizza in Voorheesville is a local ritual—with each favorite parlor full of stories and regulars who swear their go-to order is the only way to go.

I once lost track of time in a cozy Voorheesville booth, caught between the scent of rising dough and the debate over thin or thick crust. After that slice, it was clear why people here guard their pizza loyalties like family recipes. If you’re searching for your new favorite slice, this guide will help you skip the guesswork and get straight to the best Voorheesville offers. Each pick on this list serves something memorable, and you just might find yourself plotting your next meal before you finish reading.

1. Jaycee’s Pizza Depot

Jaycee’s Pizza Depot is the kind of neighborhood spot where locals linger over a second slice. Found right on Main Street, Jaycee’s has a devoted following for its dough-first philosophy—always made fresh, never rushed. The setting feels casual, but every pie is treated with care, drawing families and friends back week after week.

One afternoon, I ducked in during a rainstorm and left with a box of their signature thin-crust pizza, crisp at the edges and loaded with melted cheese. The staff made it easy to feel at home while deciding between classic options and inventive specialties.

Try the Margherita for fresh basil and a perfect cheese-to-sauce balance. Their veggie pizza is a favorite for a reason—it’s always colorful, never soggy, and distinctly crisp. Jaycee’s is where tradition meets quality, one slice at a time.

2. Brick House Pizza

Brick House Pizza has a way of turning a rainy night or quick lunch stop into a full-on comfort experience. Tucked off Maple Road, it’s a low-key staple where quality isn’t sacrificed for affordability. The prices are easy on the wallet, but the pizzas always feel generous—crust with the right amount of chew and toppings piled with intention.

My first visit came after a soccer game, with half the team in tow and everyone hungry for something more than usual. The staff handled the crowd with patience and the pies arrived quick and hot.

Their pepperoni pizza is a must, making the most of crispy edges and rich tomato sauce. For a twist, try their white pizza—ricotta, garlic, and mozzarella in every bite. Brick House is honest pizza done right.

3. Casa Mia’s

Casa Mia’s sits right on Delaware Turnpike, blending old-school charm with a menu that feels both classic and fresh. This is the spot where the sauce always tastes homemade and every pie arrives hot from the oven. Locals swear the staff remembers both your name and your favorite order, adding a personal touch to every visit.

The dining room is cozy and often filled with the smell of toasty crust. I stopped in after work and was rewarded with pizza that manages to be both light and filling—a hard trick to pull off.

Order the veggie pizza for crisp peppers and mushrooms on a thin crust, or go with a plain cheese to really taste their sweet, tangy sauce. Casa Mia’s makes every meal feel like a return home.

4. Inferno Pizzeria

Inferno Pizzeria on Western Ave draws a steady crowd from Voorheesville and beyond with its large, lively slices and quick service. This place feels like a classic pizza joint from your childhood, right down to the red booths and bubbling cheese. The scent of fresh pies hits you before you even open the door.

On my last trip, the place was buzzing with college students and families, all savoring slices bigger than their plates. There’s a relaxed, no-fuss approach here—just good food, no distractions.

The Sicilian pizza is a highlight, with its thick, airy crust and rich, savory sauce, but the plain cheese slice is a local favorite for its perfect cheese melt and light, crispy bottom. Inferno’s brings generations together over pizza worth returning for.

5. I Love Ny Pizza

I Love NY Pizza has earned its name by serving up slices that check all the New York boxes—crispy edges, chewy crust, and a sauce that’s never too sweet. It’s a hub for anyone who believes pizza should be quick, affordable, and full of flavor. The staff moves fast, but they never rush a pie, which means every order feels fresh from the oven.

One afternoon, I stopped in while running errands, and a single slice was enough to power me through the day. The atmosphere is relaxed, with locals trading stories over pizza boxes and kids choosing new topping combinations every week.

The classic cheese slice is always reliable, but the mushroom pizza deserves a mention for its generous toppings and savory depth. I Love NY Pizza is a no-fuss favorite with crowd-pleasing results.

6. Marisa’s Place

Marisa’s Place has a loyal following thanks to its classic Italian touch and inviting, friendly vibe. This family-owned spot brings a bit of Tuscan warmth to Guilderland, blending tradition with a knack for fresh ingredients. The décor sets the perfect scene for a comforting meal—think checkered tablecloths and the scent of garlic in the air.

My first visit was an easy-going dinner on a quiet weekday. Every table had at least one pizza, and for good reason. The dough is light, with just the right stretch, and the toppings never feel skimpy.

Try the Margherita for bright tomato flavor and creamy mozzarella, or branch out with their veggie pie for a colorful combination that’s always crisp. Marisa’s Place is old-world flavor, served with a smile.

7. New Village Deli & Pizza

New Village Deli & Pizza combines two cravings under one cozy roof, blending classic deli favorites with made-to-order pizza that keeps regulars coming back. It’s the go-to for a quick bite that never tastes rushed, whether you’re after a hot slice or a stacked sandwich. The space feels bright and welcoming, even when it’s filled with hungry lunch crowds.

I stopped by for a late lunch and quickly realized why this spot has its fans. Friendly service and generous portions made it easy to linger over a slice and chat with the staff.

The deluxe pizza, topped with fresh vegetables and perfectly melted cheese, is a front-runner. Pair it with a salad for the full deli experience. New Village Deli & Pizza keeps things simple and satisfying.

8. Milano Pizza

Milano Pizza has mastered the art of turning takeout into something a little special. This spot blends a wide-ranging menu with consistent quality, perfect for a night in or a quick lunch run. Orders are packed with care, and the staff always seems happy to share their favorites when you need a recommendation.

My last visit started with indecision and ended with a table full of empty plates. Their crust is golden and airy, balancing a chewy bite with a crispy finish that makes each slice memorable.

Try the spinach and ricotta pizza for a slice that’s creamy, flavorful, and slightly garlicky, or stick to the classic cheese if you like things simple. Milano’s multitasks comfort and flavor in every box.

9. Pizza Gram Plus

Pizza Gram Plus may look like a simple roadside spot, but its loyal fan base knows differently. This pizzeria stands out for its hand-tossed crust that ties every pie together—light yet substantial, landing squarely between doughy and crisp. The staff is friendly, working fast even when the counter gets busy.

I once swung by for a late dinner, expecting a basic slice, but was caught off guard by how good the veggie pizza was. The toppings tasted garden-fresh, and the portions made it easy to share or save for later.

Their white pizza, loaded with ricotta and garlic, earns plenty of repeat requests. If you like extra cheese or plenty of toppings, Pizza Gram Plus is a solid bet for a hearty meal.

10. Pizza Hut

Pizza Hut offers a familiar comfort for anyone craving a classic chain-style pizza experience. Consistency is their claim to fame—every pie comes out piping hot and reliably cheesy. The Western Ave location feels welcoming, whether you’re grabbing a quick dinner or feeding a crowd after a long day.

I remember one family night here, where the smell of baking dough instantly brought back childhood memories. The staff was quick and kept our table full of sides and steaming pizza slices, perfect for sharing.

The pan pizza is a perennial favorite, with a golden, buttery crust and a soft, pillowy bite. If you want a bit more crunch, go for their thin ‘n crispy style. Pizza Hut keeps it simple and satisfying for all tastes.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the best pizza places in Voorheesville, NY?
Some favorites among locals include Jaycee’s Pizza Depot, Brick House Pizza, Casa Mia’s, and Inferno Pizzeria. Each brings a unique style, from crisp thin crusts to classic New York slices.

Do any pizza places in Voorheesville offer delivery?
Yes, many spots such as Milano Pizza, Domino’s Pizza, and Pizza Hut offer delivery. It’s best to check their websites or call ahead for current delivery zones and times.

Are there vegetarian pizza options nearby?
Absolutely. Most pizzerias like Jaycee’s Pizza Depot and Marisa’s Place offer veggie pizzas or allow you to customize your own. Expect plenty of fresh veggies and classic cheese combos.

Can I get gluten-free pizza in Voorheesville?
Some pizzerias, including larger chains and a few local favorites, offer gluten-free crusts. Call ahead to confirm options and preparation methods for gluten sensitivity.

Are there sit-down pizza restaurants in Voorheesville?
Yes. Places like Casa Mia’s and Marisa’s Place provide a cozy dine-in experience, great for families or gatherings with friends.