Finding a great slice of pizza around Imperial, PA can feel like navigating a labyrinth with delicious rewards at every turn. Over the years, I’ve made it a mission to sample pies from every nook and cranny of this corner of western Pennsylvania, from bustling local joints tucked next to hardware stores to family-run kitchens that smell like memories. Few things measure up to the comfort of hot, cheesy pizza on a chilly evening here, or sharing slices with friends after a high school game. If your only frame of reference for good pizza is a cardboard box from a national chain, the local scene will be a revelation.
This guide is built for anyone who finds themselves weighing the age-old questions: crispy or chewy, deep-dish or thin, classic sauce or white pie? I’ve sifted through saucy debates and melted cheese ooze to highlight the standouts. Whether you want a fresh idea for Friday night, a spot to impress family, or just need the closest answer to a pizza craving, you’re in the right place. Let’s dig deeper into the ovens and discover Imperial’s best, slice by slice.
1. Fox’s Pizza Den
Fox’s Pizza Den in Imperial has the kind of small-town energy that keeps regulars coming back for more. I remember stopping in after a late shift, greeted by the aroma of bubbling cheese and fresh-baked dough. There’s a warmth here, and it goes beyond the oven.
The pizza feels sturdy and classic with a crust that’s never soggy and toppings that actually taste fresh. If you’re craving something satisfying, order the traditional hand-tossed round pizza, which strikes the right balance between chewy and crisp. Their plain cheese pizza is excellent, but if you want to branch out, try the veggie lovers’ special—generous, never skimpy on toppings.
Fox’s also excels with family-sized pies, perfect for a crowd, and their service is welcoming every time. For a local staple that lives up to its reputation, this is a slice worth seeking.
2. Don’s Pizzeria Inc
(724) 695-7477Call
Don’s Pizzeria Inc is one of those unassuming spots in Imperial that everyone whispers about when you ask where to get a good pie. My first visit was on a recommendation from a local, and I found a shop that’s become something like a second home for pizza fans.
The dough here is soft but holds up, and the cheese has just enough pull without being overwhelming. You can see real care in how each pizza is crafted. For the best introduction, order a classic pepperoni—the edges curl and crisp in a way that sets Don’s apart from the rest.
The menu stays true to tradition, and while everything’s reliable, it’s the personal attention that really makes a difference. A pie from Don’s is comfort food, plain and simple.
3. Vocelli Pizza
Vocelli Pizza is a staple for those who love a thin, flavorful crust and balanced toppings with every bite. My first introduction to Vocelli was during a quick lunch break, and somehow their pizza managed to taste just as good reheated later. That’s when I knew they were doing something right.
The dough is light with a crisp edge and there’s a tangy signature sauce that makes all the difference. The Margherita pizza hits all the right notes with its fresh basil and real mozzarella, offering a taste that feels both traditional and just a little elevated.
The menu caters to every budget, and the quick service means you’re never waiting long for quality pizza. For a reliable favorite in Imperial, Vocelli delivers.
4. Angelia’s Pizza of North Fayette
Angelia’s Pizza of North Fayette brings a sense of old-school charm to every order, and there’s real pride in every pie. My pick-up order was still piping hot by the time I got home, and each slice was just as satisfying as the last.
They specialize in classic and Sicilian pizzas, with a soft interior and crisp bottom, offering something for every mood. If you want to experience their style at its best, the Sicilian is worth the detour—airy yet hefty enough to handle a generous layer of cheese and sauce without losing its shape.
The menu is packed with specialty options, but their white pizza stands out for its garlicky depth and creamy texture. Whether you dine in or grab a quick takeout, Angelia’s delivers consistent flavor and friendly service.
5. Speedies Pizza
Speedies Pizza is that place you stumble upon between errands and end up telling everyone about. My first order was a spur-of-the-moment slice run, and the name fits—they had my pizza out fast, but with each bite you can tell speed doesn’t mean compromise.
The crust here presses a little thicker than most in the area and has a satisfying chew that only improves as you eat. The cheese has a nice stretch and their mild, herby sauce weaves everything together without overpowering. For a real sense of what Speedies does best, try their Deluxe pizza—it’s a loaded pie that still tastes balanced, not heavy.
Generous portions and easygoing service make Speedies a smart choice for those nights when only pizza will do. It’s fuss-free, reliable, and always hits the spot.
6. Garden of Eating Pizzeria
Garden of Eating Pizzeria brings something refreshing to the local pizza scene with a menu that leans creative but keeps its roots. The first time I stopped in, I noticed right away the care put into ingredient choices, which shines through in each bite.
Their hand-tossed pizzas have a bright, clean sauce and a crust that manages to be both sturdy and light. The Veggie Supreme is a go-to—fresh vegetables always taste crisp instead of overcooked, and the ratio of cheese to toppings is just right.
Prices are budget-friendly and service feels personable, making it easy to turn a quick pizza run into a regular habit. If you want a pizza with a bit of a garden vibe, this is your spot.
7. Pizza Bella
Pizza Bella in nearby Coraopolis is worth the quick drive from Imperial, especially if you appreciate a pizzeria that cares about both tradition and flavor. My last visit started with the aroma of baking dough that reminded me of family gatherings and left me with leftovers I actually looked forward to eating.
Their crust finds a happy middle ground—not too thin, not too thick—and the sauce bursts with the kind of gentle tang you only get from slow simmering. Try the Margherita pizza here; it’s layered simply with fresh mozzarella and lively basil, showing off the kitchen’s lighter touch.
Pizza Bella’s staff makes everyone feel like a neighbor, and the menu has something for picky eaters and adventurous types alike. It’s a spot that serves comfort, slice after slice.
8. Gianni’s Pizza
Gianni’s Pizza, tucked off Steubenville Pike, has a knack for making you feel right at home from the minute you call in an order. My first time trying it, the staff chatted like old friends, and the pizza was piping hot and full of flavor.
Their pies lean hearty—with a crisp crust that holds up well and toppings that taste fresh rather than pre-packed. If you’re open to something unexpected, their specialty Spinach and Ricotta pizza is a standout. The balance of creamy and earthy flavors sets it apart from the usual options around Imperial.
Portions are generous and ideal for sharing, but you might just keep it all for yourself. For a relaxed, no-frills pizza night, Gianni’s rarely misses.
9. Police Station Pizza
Police Station Pizza brings a different experience to the Imperial area, home to their signature square, Italian-style pies. The first time I visited, I was skeptical—toppings go on after baking—but that first bite made me a convert. The crust is airy yet has that satisfying crunch underneath, and each tray gets loaded up fresh so nothing turns soggy.
Ordering by the slice or tray lets you get as adventurous—or as classic—as you like. The cheese blend has a distinct, mellow flavor without being heavy, and the homemade sauce shows off just the right touch of tanginess. Try a tray with banana peppers and fresh mushrooms, for something outside the standard pepperoni.
This spot is as casual as it gets, with quick service and plenty of seats for a low-key dinner. Police Station Pizza leans simple but does the basics remarkably well.
10. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Steubenville Pike is the go-to spot for nights when hunger strikes and time is short. I’ve lost count of how many late study sessions or game nights have been saved by their quick delivery and consistent pies. There’s a reason Domino’s fills the craving for comfort with just a few taps on the app.
The menu covers a wide range, but the Handmade Pan Pizza stands out for its soft center and crispy, buttery edge. Mix things up by customizing your order—vegetarian options and classic Margherita deliver satisfying flavor every time.
If you want a reliable, value-driven option with plenty of choices, Domino’s fits the bill without surprises. It’s efficient, fuss-free, and always predictable in the best way possible.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best pizza places in Imperial, PA?
The best pizza places in Imperial include Fox’s Pizza Den, Don’s Pizzeria Inc, Vocelli Pizza, Angelia’s Pizza of North Fayette, and Speedies Pizza. Each offers something a little different, so there’s a good match for every kind of pizza fan.
Do any pizza places in Imperial deliver?
Yes, many spots such as Domino’s, Vocelli Pizza, Angelia’s Pizza, and Fox’s Pizza Den offer delivery. Most allow you to order online or by phone for quick service.
Is vegetarian pizza available in Imperial?
You’ll find vegetarian-friendly options at almost every pizza shop in the area. Look for classics like Margherita or Veggie Supreme at places like Garden of Eating Pizzeria, Pizza Bella, and Domino’s.
Which pizza shops use fresh ingredients?
Local favorites like Garden of Eating Pizzeria and Gianni’s Pizza are known for fresh toppings and quality dough, while even larger names like Vocelli and Domino’s aim for consistency in every pie.
Are there any sit-down pizza restaurants in Imperial?
Yes, several pizza spots in Imperial have dine-in areas, such as Angelia’s Pizza of North Fayette and Gianni’s Pizza, for those who prefer to enjoy their pizza fresh from the oven.