Searching for the best pizza in Sacramento is a bit like searching for lost treasure—there are plenty of maps, but only a few slices truly deliver gold. Sacramento’s pizza scene is a mix of hole-in-the-wall joints, buzzing taprooms, and family recipes that have survived the test of time. During my own search through the city’s neighborhoods, I learned that pizza here is about tradition, invention, and a sprinkle of local flavor.
Each pizzeria on this list has earned its dough. I’ve sat in booths with bubbling cheese, tasted cranky crusts straight from stone ovens, and even argued with friends over whether thick or thin crust reigns supreme. Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through, this guide will point you to pies that invite sharing, talking, and maybe even a happy argument about which slice is king. Sacramento’s best pizzas aren’t just food—they’re experiences.
Where to find the best pizza in Sacramento, CA
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Sacramento, CA:
- Chicago Fire
- One Speed
- Paesano’s Pizzeria
- Roma Pizzeria
- Masullo Pizza
- Taste of Tuscany
- Zelda’s Original Gourmet Pizza
- Slice of Old Sacramento
- Upper Crust Pizza
- Uncle Vito’s Slice of NY
1. Chicago Fire
Chicago Fire serves up authentic Chicago-style pizza right in the heart of Sacramento. The first time I slid a fork into their deep-dish, gooey cheese stretched for days and the savory tomato sauce actually tasted like tomatoes. Every bite reminded me why this spot is a staple for both locals and visitors.
What makes Chicago Fire stand out is their commitment to the real Windy City formula: a golden, buttery crust topped with robust sausage and a sauce seasoned just right. They also offer crispy thin-crust pies for those who crave crunch.
Try their Great Chicago Fire Pizza—it’s got a gentle heat, layers of flavor, and a cloud of bubbling cheese. You’ll understand why this spot is more than just another pizza joint.
2. One Speed
One Speed offers wood-fired pizzas and a laid-back vibe that fits the East Sac neighborhood perfectly. The atmosphere is relaxed, with bicycles lining the walls and conversation flowing as easily as their house-made lemonade. I’ve gathered with friends here, and the pizza always feels fresh, bright, and never heavy.
The key to One Speed’s charm is their focus on seasonal, local toppings that taste crisp and lively. Their crust is thin, chewy, and just the right amount of charred.
Order the Margherita pizza for its pure, simple flavors or the Vegetable pizza packed with market-fresh produce. Every slice shows off the kitchen’s attention to detail and love for quality ingredients.
3. Paesano’s Pizzeria
Paesano’s Pizzeria is a Midtown landmark, where the scent of fresh basil and roasted garlic hits you before you even step inside. I remember my first visit, ducking in on a rainy afternoon and finding the dining room packed with happy chatter and clinking glasses. There’s an unmistakable neighborhood energy that instantly makes you feel at home.
What sets Paesano’s apart is their inventive pizza menu. You won’t just find the classics here—try their artichoke and garlic pie or one loaded with sun-dried tomatoes and pesto. Each pizza arrives on a thin, chewy crust straight from the brick oven, every ingredient thoughtfully placed.
Order the Paesano Special Pizza. The blend of cheeses and the bright tomato sauce will pull you back for another visit. Here, pizza is more than a meal—it’s a moment to savor.
4. Roma Pizzeria
Roma Pizzeria has the cozy, retro feel of an old-school neighborhood spot, where regulars know each other by name and the pizzas come out piping hot. My first slice here happened by chance—a friend insisted we stop after class—and it quickly turned into a new favorite. The crust hits a sweet spot between crispy and chewy, never overshadowing the rich, flavorful toppings.
What makes Roma Pizzeria unique is its dedication to the classics. The sauce tastes fresh, the cheese stretches, and each topping from mushrooms to olives gets its moment to shine.
The go-to order is the Vegetarian Pizza. It’s loaded with plenty of garden-fresh veggies, all layered generously on a golden base. Roma keeps it simple—and that’s why it works so well.
5. Masullo Pizza
Masullo Pizza feels like a hidden gem tucked away in Land Park. On my first visit, I watched the pizzaiolo slide dough into a roaring wood oven—the aroma alone had me sold. The mood is warm and casual, making this spot perfect for weeknight dinners where you actually want to linger at the table.
Masullo stands out because their crust is naturally leavened. That means every pizza has a light, airy chew and a touch of sourdough tang, balanced by locally sourced toppings.
Order the Margherita or Bianco pizzas. Both showcase Masullo’s obsession with quality—simple, elegant, and built for those who believe crust matters just as much as toppings.
6. Taste of Tuscany
Taste of Tuscany brings a slice of Italian countryside to Sacramento. I stopped by after hearing whispers of their loyal following, and found a dining room buzzing with families, friends, and the scent of slow-simmered tomato sauce. The homemade dough is light and airy, forming the backbone of every pizza they serve.
What sets Taste of Tuscany apart is the way each pie feels handcrafted from scratch. Toppings are fresh, portions are generous, and each pizza is baked to golden perfection. It’s comfort food, but with just enough flair to keep things interesting.
Order the Tuscany Special Pizza if you want a real highlight. It’s a medley of crisp veggies and cheese that captures the spirit of Tuscan kitchens—honest, satisfying, and full of flavor.
7. Zelda’s Original Gourmet Pizza
Zelda’s Original Gourmet Pizza is a Midtown icon—dimly lit, unpretentious, and packed with loyal regulars. My first pie here? Deep-dish, impossibly thick, and so rich with cheese and tomatoes that my fork barely stood a chance. Every order is made with patience, and that care shines through in each hearty bite.
Zelda’s stands out for its unapologetic embrace of deep-dish crust that’s both buttery and crisp. The sauce, with its touch of herbs, is ladled over gooey layers of cheese, making each slice a commitment and a conversation starter.
Order their Veggie Special or the cheese and tomato classic if you really want to see how Zelda’s redefines Sacramento pizza indulgence.
8. Slice of Old Sacramento
Slice of Old Sacramento does pizza with a nostalgic twist, tucked into the cobblestone bustle of the historic district. I grabbed a late slice here once after exploring the riverfront, and the thin crust was still hot from the oven and perfectly foldable—just right for eating as you wander the streets.
What makes Slice of Old Sacramento memorable is its classic counter-service charm and quick, friendly service. The pizza is always fresh, with a crunchy base that holds up under layers of melty cheese and bright sauce.
If you’re unsure what to get, the Supreme Pizza is loaded with crisp veggies and cheeses that show off the shop’s knack for fast, quality pies. It’s Old Sacramento’s slice of comfort.
9. Upper Crust Pizza
Upper Crust Pizza is one of those downtown spots you stumble into once and end up returning to whenever you want reliable, delicious pizza. My lunch breaks here mean a warm slice in one hand and a view of K Street through the window in the other. The pies come out fast, hot, and piled with toppings.
Upper Crust stands out for its classic approach and consistently good crust: golden, just the right level of chewy, and never greasy. They let the toppings shine—a bright sauce, stretchy cheese, and a generous hand with veggies.
If you want the best of everything, try the Veggie Deluxe pizza. It’s layered with crisp vegetables and melts together into a satisfying, comforting bite.
10. Uncle Vito’s Slice of NY
Uncle Vito’s Slice of NY nails that classic New York street-corner experience—right in Midtown Sacramento. I remember dropping in late one night and grabbing a hot, foldable slice that tasted straight out of Manhattan. There’s an effortless charm here, and the pizza is always just the right amount of cheesy and chewy.
Uncle Vito’s stands out for its commitment to real, no-nonsense NY-style slices: thin crust, bold sauce, and enough flexibility to fold without flopping. It’s a slice meant for eating with your hands, preferably while talking about something other than the weather.
Order the White Spinach Pizza if you want to try something that’s both classic and a bit unexpected. Each bite is full of flavor and attitude.
More Things to Try in Sacramento, CA
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the most popular style of pizza in Sacramento?
Sacramento’s pizza is a true mix—deep-dish, thin crust, Neapolitan, and NY-style all have a following. Locals often debate between classic Sacramento thin crust and hearty Chicago-style deep-dish.
Are there good vegetarian or vegan pizza options in Sacramento?
Absolutely. Many places like Masullo, One Speed, and Paesano’s serve up delicious vegetarian pizzas, while spots such as MOD Pizza and One Speed offer solid vegan options too.
Where can I get pizza for a big group or party?
Large menu spots like Mountain Mike’s, Federalist Public House, and Original Pete’s make it easy to feed a crowd. These places welcome big parties and have the space for them.
Which pizzerias are open late?
A handful of favorites, including Uncle Vito’s, Luigi’s Pizza Parlor, and Famous Pizza, cater to late-night cravings and keep their ovens running after most places wind down.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Sacramento?
Yes, you’ll find gluten-free crusts at One Speed, Paesano’s, MOD Pizza, and several others around the city. Just ask and they’ll point you to the best choices.