If you’re hunting for the best pizza in Rochester, NY, you’re in for an adventure. As someone who’s circled Monroe Avenue far too many times debating the “crunch factor” of a perfect slice, I can promise Rochester doesn’t disappoint. This city thinks about pizza the way artists think about color. Every neighborhood nook and bustling downtown spot has its take, whether it’s molten cheese with crisp corners or that barely-there flop you only get from a perfect fold.
Finding your favorite here isn’t about one pizza to rule them all—it’s about discovering pies that tell their own stories. Through carb-fueled nights and kitchen-counter debates over whether thin or thick crust reigns supreme, I’ve tasted my way across Rochester’s pizza map. The journey isn’t just delicious, it’s revealing. Whether you seek a classic Margherita, crave a hot, stuffed calzone, or want to try new takes on traditional recipes, you’re exactly where you should be. Let’s dig in.
Where to find the best pizza in Rochester, NY
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Rochester, NY:
- Tony D’s
- Veneto Restaurant
- Restaurant Fiorella
- Create A Pizza
- Tony Pepperoni
- Galleria Pizza
- Pizza Wizard
- The Gate House Cafe
- Cinelli’s Pizza Ristorante
- Blaze Pizza
1. Tony D’s
Tony D’s feels like a place where pizza lovers gather and leave full, not just in the stomach but in spirit. The vibe is sleek but warm, thanks to its canal-side setting and open kitchen. I once sat in front of their wood-fired oven, mesmerized as the flames licked the dough, knowing something special was coming my way.
The crust comes out thin, crisp, and charmingly charred—exactly how it should be. Try the Margherita; the fresh basil and melted mozzarella combine perfectly with the smoky flavor. The Bianca is also a revelation, especially if you love bright ricotta and garlic.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free options mean no one’s left out. Tony D’s sets a high bar for artisan pizza in Rochester.
2. Veneto Restaurant
Veneto Restaurant brings a slice of Italy to Rochester’s East End. Nestled in a 150-year-old brick building, the cozy, inviting space makes you want to linger. I remember sitting near the open kitchen, watching chefs master the wood-fired oven and feeling the anticipation build as the aroma of fresh dough drifted over tables.
The heart of Veneto is its pizza, crafted daily from scratch and fired to order. The ultra-thin crust comes out crisp, bubbling with charred edges and that unmistakable smoky flavor. I recommend the Quattro Formaggi for its blend of cheeses or the classic Margherita—both shine with fresh ingredients and simple elegance.
With vegan, vegetarian, and gluten free options, Veneto makes sure everyone finds their own perfect pie.
3. Restaurant Fiorella
Restaurant Fiorella sits at the heart of Rochester Public Market, surrounded by fresh energy and local flavor. The space feels both rustic and energetic, blending cozy candlelit tables with the swirl of market life. On my first visit, I was sold by the aroma alone—yeast, tomatoes, and olive oil in perfect harmony.
Their commitment to local ingredients shines through every bite. The Margherita Pizza here is an education in balance: a blistered crust, bright tomato sauce, and basil so fresh it almost crackles. Another standout is the Funghi Pizza, their ode to mushrooms that’s savory and earthy without being heavy.
Vegetarian and vegan options round out the menu, so everyone finds something worth craving. Fiorella puts the “art” in artisanal pizza.
4. Create A Pizza
Create A Pizza on Monroe Ave proves there’s no wrong answer when it comes to toppings—or timing. After a late-night craving landed me here, I watched my custom pizza go from dough to done in under three minutes, piping hot and made-to-order. The open kitchen and the friendly crew take the guesswork out of getting exactly what you want.
What’s special is full control: pick every topping, sauce, and style. Try their classic NY-style pizza for simplicity, or embrace your inner mad scientist with a personal pie loaded just the way you like it. The house-made dough and sauces set everything apart, making even a basic cheese pizza feel fresh.
Vegan and gluten-free cauliflower crusts are available, so everyone leaves happy.
5. Tony Pepperoni
Tony Pepperoni has all the hallmarks of a classic pizzeria—a cheerful, bustling energy and slices that feel like comfort food done right. My first encounter with their pizza was after a long day, and their pillowy, chewy crust had me plotting a return trip before I’d even finished eating.
This spot delivers on both traditional and inventive pizzas. Their Pepperoni Pizza stands out, boasting crisp-edged cups and zesty sauce, while the White Pizza brings garlicky goodness and a creamy blend of cheeses. It’s clear every pie gets full attention, whether you take it to-go or grab a seat.
The welcoming atmosphere and consistent flavors explain why locals keep Tony Pepperoni on speed dial for pizza cravings.
6. Galleria Pizza
Galleria Pizza sits at the heart of downtown, a go-to for anyone craving a fast, satisfying slice in Rochester. My office days near East Main always seemed less tedious when lunch meant a hot slice here. There’s something about the smell of their freshly baked dough that resets a day.
For over two decades, Galleria has thrived on quality and consistency. Their Cheese Pizza is blissfully simple, balancing gooey cheese with a sauce that hints at herbs and sweetness. If you’re in the mood for something more, their Veggie Pizza is loaded but never soggy—fresh, colorful, and crisp.
Lunch specials, quick service, and friendly staff make Galleria a place people keep coming back to, whether ordering out or eating in.
7. Pizza Wizard
Pizza Wizard is a quirky, magical corner where pizza dreams come true on Clinton Ave. The first time I visited, I was struck by how this tiny shop punches above its weight with creativity and real-deal flavors. Step in, and it’s all about the aroma of fresh dough and inventive toppings.
The menu is imaginative and playful, but the skill is seriously sharp. Try the Brooklyn—a crisp, yet chewy crust that’s the perfect canvas for tangy tomato sauce and a generous topping stretch. The Magic Mushroom also deserves applause, with earthy, roasted mushrooms and fresh herbs that taste like a chef’s favorite experiment gone right.
Every slice is thoughtfully constructed, making Pizza Wizard a refreshing twist on Rochester’s pizza roster.
8. The Gate House Cafe
The Gate House Cafe sits tucked inside the Village Gate complex, where eclectic art meets the irresistible scent of a stone oven. My first meal here was a midday pick-me-up that started with fantastic service and ended with pizza perfection. This spot strikes a balance between cozy and contemporary.
Known for creative pies, The Gate House leans on high-quality, local ingredients. Order the Ellwanger if you like bright pesto and roasted veggies or go for the fan-favorite Cobb Pizza—think blue cheese, tomatoes, and crisp lettuce, all atop a tender crust. Each pizza feels crafted and memorable.
Options for vegetarians, vegans, and those eating gluten-free mean everyone at the table leaves satisfied.
9. Cinelli’s Pizza Ristorante
Cinelli’s Pizza Ristorante feels like the classic neighborhood Italian spot, where regulars know the staff by name and newcomers soon do too. The first time I stopped in, I saw dough flying and families crowding around big, shareable pies. It has that old-school, all-are-welcome atmosphere.
What makes Cinelli’s special is their commitment to tradition and generous portions. The Grandma Pizza is a standout, featuring a thick but airy crust, a robust tomato sauce, and golden cheese layered with care. For something unique, try their Veggie Lovers Pizza; it bursts with fresh toppings and crisp edges.
Open for every meal, Cinelli’s provides classic comfort with plenty of vegetarian and vegan choices.
10. Blaze Pizza
+1 585-270-8222
See Menu
Blaze Pizza at Jefferson Plaza in Henrietta is all about speed, choice, and a satisfyingly crisp crust. My first experience was a lunch rush where I built a custom pie and watched it fire in their blazing-hot oven, emerging artisan-style in minutes. The cheerful staff matched the pace, making the process smooth for everyone in line.
The beauty here is total freedom: pile on classic or inventive toppings without worrying about the price. Try their Red Vine Pizza—fresh mozzarella, cherry tomatoes, basil, and a zesty red sauce—or get creative with a signature build-your-own. The crust always comes out just right, crackling on the bottom with every bite.
Vegetarian options are abundant, ensuring everyone finds something crave-worthy in the lineup.
More Things to Try in Rochester, NY
Frequently Asked Questions
What style of pizza is most popular in Rochester, NY?
Rochester loves variety, but New York-style thin crust and Sicilian pan pizza both have devoted followings. Many local spots offer their own creative spins alongside these classics.
Are there good vegan or vegetarian pizza options in Rochester?
Absolutely. Many pizzerias, like Restaurant Fiorella, The Gate House Cafe, and Blaze Pizza, offer vegan cheese, plant-based toppings, and even gluten-free crusts, so everyone can dig in.
Can I find gluten-free pizza in Rochester?
Yes. Plenty of pizza places—including Tony D’s and Create A Pizza—provide gluten-free crusts, most often a cauliflower or rice flour base, crafted to be safe and tasty for all diets.
Which pizzerias offer delivery or takeout in Rochester?
Most pizzerias on this list offer both, with some working through popular apps like Grubhub and DoorDash. Local classics like Galleria Pizza, Pudgie’s Pizza, and Nino’s Pizza are go-tos for quick takeout or home delivery.
What are some must-try pizza toppings unique to Rochester?
You’ll find all the standards, but Rochester pizzerias don’t shy away from bold moves. Try locally grown veggies, hot sauce drizzles, or special blends of cheese that reflect each spot’s personality. Specialty pies with spinach, artichoke, or ricotta also stand out.
Is it easy to find late-night pizza in Rochester?
Definitely. Many places—like Galleria Pizza and Tony Pepperoni—stay open late, making it easy to satisfy those after-hours cravings.
Are there any pizza spots near the Rochester Public Market?
Yes, Restaurant Fiorella sits right at the Public Market, offering handmade, market-fresh pizza with unbeatable local character.
Do local pizza places offer catering for events?
Several do, including Galleria Pizza and Pudgie’s Pizza. They provide catering trays and flexible packages, ideal for feeding a crowd at family gatherings or parties.