Finding good pizza can feel like a quest. In Germantown, WI, you won’t need a treasure map, but a guide can make the choice a lot easier. I’ve tasted my way through classic pizzerias, family-run favorites, and grab-and-go spots to help you find the slice that fits your cravings. Whether you prefer a gooey cheese pull, crisply-fired crust, or bold toppings, Germantown has options that aren’t just filling—they’re memorable.
What stands out about pizza in this town is a blend of tradition and creativity. Some places stick to tried-and-true recipes, while others get inventive. I’ve sat at booths packed with weekend crowds, chatted with local owners tossing dough behind the counter, and even slipped away with a piping hot box for an easy dinner. If you’re ready to meet authentic flavors and maybe even new favorites, keep reading—there’s a slice here that belongs on your plate.
1. Old Germantown
Old Germantown feels like a secret gem tucked just off Pleasant View Drive. Stepping inside, you’ll catch the aroma of baking dough and herbs, promising classic comfort. The dining room is cozy and welcoming, making it a spot where conversations stretch and plates get cleaned. Every table is looked after with care, and there’s a sense the staff know a good pizza means a happy guest.
Their pizza is all about balance—crispy crust, tangy tomato sauce, and generous cheese. The sausage and mushroom pizza highlights Old Germantown’s knack for getting toppings just right. If you’re after a lighter bite, the margherita is refreshingly simple. This is the place for pizza that’s thoughtfully made, not just fast. Dinner here feels unrushed, just the way pizza should be enjoyed.
2. Domino’s Pizza
Domino’s Pizza on Mequon Rd is where I end up when I want a quick fix that’s both reliable and surprisingly satisfying. The crust is always perfectly baked—whether you’re into thin-crust edge or thick, chewy pan style. The place moves fast, perfect for a lunch break or late-night craving.
The standout here is the Parmesan Stuffed Crust—salty and cheesy, it turns a regular slice into something you actually look forward to finishing. New York Style pepperoni pizza is another personal favorite: foldable, hot, and loaded with that signature Domino’s seasoning.
Go for the value deals to mix and match if you want to sample more. It’s not just about speed—Domino’s delivers consistency and flavor every time.
3. Marko’s Pizza
Marko’s Pizza is the kind of place you almost hope others don’t find out about. Tucked along Pilgrim Rd, it feels like an old-school pizzeria with a loyal following. My first bite here set the bar high—generous cheese, a crust with real snap, and toppings that actually taste fresh.
What separates Marko’s from the rest is their house sauce. It has a bold, slightly sweet flavor that pulls everything together. The sausage and green pepper pizza is a standout, piled high and cooked until the edges are golden. If you’re into classics, their cheese pizza can hold its own against any in town.
Order for takeout or grab a booth for dinner. The pizza quality never disappoints, and you’ll see why regulars keep coming back.
4. Aldo’s Pizza & Pub
Aldo’s Pizza & Pub on Pilgrim Rd brings together the comfort of a corner bar with the heart of a good pizzeria. The atmosphere is relaxed and just lively enough for families or a casual night out with friends. I always notice the regulars—there’s a reason people settle in and linger over their meals here.
Aldo’s crust walks the line between crisp and chewy, giving every bite just enough texture. The veggie pizza is a highlight, with fresh peppers and tomatoes layered over a bright, herby sauce. Try their signature four-cheese pizza for a gooey experience that feels generous but not overdone.
The pub setting means you can pair your favorite pie with a cold drink, and nobody rushes you to finish. It’s local, easy, and never tries too hard—Aldo’s just gets pizza right.
5. Pizza Hut – Closed
Pizza Hut on Mequon Rd was once a regular stop for anyone craving a fast slice or a classic family dinner. There’s something nostalgic about those red roof days, the stringy cheese pulls, and the unmistakable pan pizza aroma. Even now, the memory of their buttery crust and signature red sauce stands out.
The Meat Lovers® and Original Stuffed Crust® pizzas were crowd favorites. I remember many game nights and birthdays centered around their iconic deep-dish pies. The flavor always leaned on the bold and familiar—gooey cheese, crisp-edged crust, and plenty of toppings.
This location may be closed, but for those who grew up with Pizza Hut in town, the memories and flavors still linger. Sometimes, you just can’t OutPizza the Hut.
6. Mama Mia’s
(262) 242-2340Call
Mama Mia’s on Mequon Rd is a classic stop when you want a touch of old-school Italian comfort. This spot draws regulars for its generous portions and a crust that’s always light yet packed with flavor. There’s a warmth here, both in the service and in the way each pizza lands on the table.
The cheese pizza here is a blueprint for simple satisfaction—gooey, inviting, and best enjoyed hot. If you’re in the mood for something punchier, try a veggie or mushroom pie; the toppings keep their taste and freshness long after the first slice.
It’s a little slice of tradition in a busy world, and if you love classic pizza with a no-fuss style, Mama Mia’s rarely disappoints.
7. Domino’s Partners Foundation
Domino’s Partners Foundation might sound like another pizza spot, but it’s actually the heart behind the brand. While you won’t find slices served from this address, the Foundation plays a big role in supporting Domino’s team members and communities. That spirit of care is reflected at every Germantown location, where staff go the extra mile.
Ordering from Domino’s in Germantown means your meal comes from people supported by their own community—a detail that shows in the friendly, reliable service. The menu is the same, so you’ll still get your favorite pepperoni, veggie, or thin-crust pizza.
The Partners Foundation highlights how Domino’s gives back behind the scenes, making every pizza a little more meaningful if you care about supporting good workplaces.
8. Pizza Hut Express
Pizza Hut Express on County Line Rd is a grab-and-go solution for anyone with a pizza craving and little time to spare. There’s no fuss here—just reliable, hot pizza ready in a snap. It’s the kind of place I stop at on a rushed day when a sit-down meal isn’t an option.
The cheese personal pan pizza hits the spot—crusty edges, gooey center, and a salty tang that reminds you of classic big-brand pizza. You can grab a pepperoni or veggie pie, too, and the taste is exactly what you hope for from a Pizza Hut: bold, cheesy, and satisfying.
For a quick lunch or simple snack, Pizza Hut Express delivers every time. There’s comfort in knowing that your pizza will be ready almost instantly.
9. GrinderVille Grinders, Pizza and Calzones
GrinderVille Grinders, Pizza and Calzones brings serious flavor to Menomonee Falls, just a short drive from Germantown. It’s a spot that feels more like a friendly neighborhood hangout than a typical pizza joint. My last visit involved chilling with free WiFi, catching up on news, and enjoying the kind of pizza you want to linger over.
Their pizza stands out for its crust—perfectly crisp, with plenty of Wisconsin cheese that stretches for days. If you want to mix it up, the veggie pizza is loaded with fresh toppings, and their calzones somehow manage to stay light but filling.
But don’t miss their specialty: oven-baked grinders. Pair one with a pizza for the table, and you’ll get why GrinderVille has a devoted local following. Great food takes a bit longer here, and it’s always worth the wait.
10. Carol Ann’s Pizza
Carol Ann’s Pizza in Hubertus is worth the short drive for anyone in Germantown looking to shake up their routine. The dough here is made fresh every day, giving each pizza a home-baked character that’s hard to forget. Whether you dine in or grab a box to go, you can count on friendly service and flexible options.
If you’re gluten-free, their specialty dough lets you join in the fun. The margherita pizza is a favorite of mine, with bright tomato, gooey cheese, and basil that tastes straight from the garden. Each bite tastes lively and satisfying.
Carol Ann’s is perfect for parties, laid-back dinners, or just whenever you want pizza made with extra care. Check their specials for a little surprise every visit.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most popular pizza places in Germantown, WI?
Some of the top spots include Old Germantown, Marko’s Pizza, Aldo’s Pizza & Pub, Mama Mia’s, and Domino’s. Each has its own style, so there’s something for every taste.
Are there gluten-free pizza options in Germantown?
Yes, places like Carol Ann’s Pizza offer gluten-free dough, and several chains provide gluten-free crusts. Always double-check before ordering.
Can I get pizza delivered in Germantown?
Most pizzerias including Domino’s, Marko’s, and Papa Johns offer delivery. Some local places provide carryout and delivery, so you won’t go hungry.
Which pizza spots have vegetarian options?
You can find veggie pizzas at nearly every location. Mama Mia’s, Aldo’s Pizza & Pub, and the big chains all serve up vegetarian-friendly pies.
Is there a place for quick, takeout pizza?
Pizza Hut Express and Domino’s are both solid for fast, ready-to-go pizzas. Many others offer call-ahead ordering to save you time.
Do local pizza restaurants cater for events or offer party sizes?
Many spots like Carol Ann’s and GrinderVille handle small parties or large orders. Contact them directly to set up your next gathering.
Where can I find the best thin crust or pan pizza in Germantown?
Old Germantown is known for a crisp, classic crust, while Domino’s does a solid pan-style and thin crust. Try a few to find your favorite.