Few foods inspire more debate than pizza. Clearwater, FL, is no exception. Tucked between sunrise views and sugar-soft sand, this city’s pizza scene is packed with surprises. I remember my first slice in Clearwater—thin, blistered crust with fresh basil, eaten at a patio table as the evening breeze rolled in. That experience was a turning point. Since then, I’ve made a mission out of trying as many local spots as possible.
This guide follows the flavor trail across Clearwater’s wide spectrum of pizzerias, from generations-old classics to playful newcomers pushing boundaries. Whether you’re a deep-dish devotee, a Neapolitan purist, or someone who thinks pineapple deserves a place at the table, you’ll find options worth your time. Trust that the slices ahead have been tasted, scrutinized, and celebrated. Your next favorite pizza just might be waiting in the unlikely corner booth or at a sprawling waterfront deck—and finding it is half the fun.
Where to find the best pizza in Clearwater, FL
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Clearwater, FL:
- Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza
- Gondolier Pizza Italian Restaurant
- King’s Pizza
- Roundabout Pizza
- Mellow Mushroom Clearwater
- Paul’s Chicago Pizza
- Country Pizza Italian Grill
- Johnny’s Italian Restaurant
- Monty’s Pizza
- We The Pizza
1. Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza
Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza earns its reputation one slice at a time. The moment you walk in, the scent from that coal oven takes over—smoky, inviting, absolutely distinct. The crust comes out blistered and crisp, just the way it should be. It makes even the simplest Margherita feel special.
On my last visit, I shared a table with locals who wouldn’t talk about anything but the white pizza. Now I see why—the blend of ricotta, garlic, and mozzarella has its own cult following. Try their “Cristino’s Special” if you want a little bit of everything.
Vegetarians and gluten-free diners feel at home here, thanks to a thoughtful menu. Whether you eat in or take out, Cristino’s brings the kind of old-school character Clearwater’s pizza lovers crave.
2. Gondolier Pizza Italian Restaurant
Gondolier Pizza Italian Restaurant sits right off the beach, where bold flavors and comfort come standard. This spot delivers more than just pizza—it feels like home for anyone craving big portions and genuine service. I once stopped in after a swim, famished, and left wondering how I’d ever finish a slice that generous.
The “Super Special” pizza does not hold back. Piled high with fresh veggies and gooey cheese, it’s a favorite among regulars. Classic cheese and Margherita remain reliable picks for those who prefer things simple.
Options for vegetarians, vegans, and the gluten-free crowd abound, including customizable pies. Breakfast pizza? Yes, they make that happen too. Gondolier’s blend of tradition and flexibility keeps the whole table happy, any time of day.
3. King’s Pizza
King’s Pizza offers the kind of no-nonsense, flavorful slices that most pizza devotees secretly crave. Open late, this spot becomes a magnet for hungry beachgoers and night owls alike. I once grabbed a slice at midnight here—crisp crust, bubbling cheese, and just enough garlic to keep things interesting.
Their “King’s Deluxe” is a top pick, stacked with peppers, onions, and mushrooms, showing off their classic approach. Cheese purists will enjoy their by-the-slice flexibility, each served piping hot and loaded with toppings.
Vegan and vegetarian options feel built in, not tacked on. For anyone searching for fast, honest pizza by the shore, King’s gives every reason to come back for more.
4. Roundabout Pizza
Roundabout Pizza sits just off Clearwater’s iconic roundabout, but its flavors are anything but routine. The secret here is their paper-thin crust, made fresh every morning with local ingredients. Even after a busy beach day, I remember how light and crisp each slice tasted—never weighed down, always packed with genuine flavor.
The “Veggie Dream” is a standout, loaded generously with market-fresh produce that still has plenty of bite. Every pizza is made-to-order, so you get something that feels truly personal.
Both vegan and vegetarian options are part of the menu’s DNA, not afterthoughts, making Roundabout a smart pick for plant-based eaters. Takeout is quick, delivery reliable, and every box comes stacked with Clearwater sunshine.
5. Mellow Mushroom Clearwater
Mellow Mushroom Clearwater takes pizza night up a notch. Their stone-baked crust is a chewy, golden wonder, and the menu reads like a wish list for creative eaters. On my first visit, the funky art and laid-back vibe made me linger long after the last bite.
The “Kosmic Karma” pizza is a must order—think rich red sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, and a pesto swirl to finish. Every pie has its signature flair, with choices for carnivores, vegetarians, and plant-based enthusiasts. Gluten-free? They’ve got you covered too.
Portions are hearty and flavors stay bright. Whether you dine on the patio or carry out, Mellow Mushroom makes it clear pizza can be playful and still satisfy the purists, right here in Clearwater.
6. Paul’s Chicago Pizza
Paul’s Chicago Pizza brings a slice of the Windy City to Clearwater. Here, deep-dish is more than a novelty—it’s an art form. The crust is buttery, the sauce chunky and bright, striking a balance you don’t always find this far south. My first forkful was all oozy cheese and fresh tomato, and I finally understood the hype.
The stuffed spinach pizza deserves special mention, winning points with both locals and visitors. Those in the mood for something lighter should check out their thin crust, which still delivers on flavor.
Vegetarian choices feel right at home on the Paul’s menu. If you’re longing for that Chicago hit or just want a hearty, satisfying meal, this is the pie to beat.
7. Country Pizza Italian Grill
Country Pizza Italian Grill is a spot where locals go to unwind and savor hearty, honest pizza. Generous portions and a cozy atmosphere set the stage for a memorable meal. My last visit started with a friendly greeting and ended with a box of leftovers—and that’s a recurring theme here.
Their “Country Special” stands out, loaded with crisp veggies and a cheese layer that stretches for days. Every crust gets just the right amount of char, giving the pie a toasty, fragrant finish.
Vegan and vegetarian pies are thoughtfully prepared, and there’s something for every taste. For anyone who values tradition and comfort over trends, Country Pizza Italian Grill feels like home, bite after bite.
8. Johnny’s Italian Restaurant
Johnny’s Italian Restaurant blends family charm with clear dedication to quality. It’s the kind of place where regulars never need to see the menu, and newcomers instantly feel like insiders. One early dinner turned into a leisurely meal because the staff treated us like old friends.
The standout is Johnny’s “Old World” pizza, offering a perfect balance of tangy sauce, stretchy mozzarella, and toppings that don’t skimp. Their crust leans crisp but never dry, pleasing both thin and “not too thin” fans.
Vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free choices feature as genuine stars, not just afterthoughts. Whether dining in or taking out, Johnny’s keeps classic Italian spirit alive, one slice at a time.
9. Monty’s Pizza
Monty’s Pizza has mastered the art of the neighborhood pizzeria. Expect friendly faces, prompt service, and classic pies that keep regulars loyal. I landed here on a whim and quickly understood why families return week after week.
The “Monty’s Supreme” deserves top billing, layered with plenty of mushrooms, crisp onions, and bell peppers. Each bite bursts with classic, well-seasoned flavor that feels familiar yet never dull.
Vegetarian options are a given, and special requests are always met with a nod. Whether you’re in for takeout or want to linger over a leisurely dinner, Monty’s offers comfort without compromise in Clearwater’s pizza lineup.
10. We The Pizza
We The Pizza feels both playful and serious about its craft. Every visit comes with that fresh-baked aroma and fast, friendly counter service. I once ducked in during a spring shower and found the vibe as bright as the Florida sun outside.
The “White Pie” is a crowd-pleaser, with creamy ricotta and a garlicky kick that sets it apart. Adventurous eaters will want to try their roasted veggie options—bold without being overpowering.
Vegetarian and vegan creations are woven into the menu, not just tacked on. Whether you’re grabbing a whole pie or just a slice after the beach, We The Pizza adds a fresh note to Clearwater’s pizza scene.
More Things to Try in Clearwater, FL
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What pizza places in Clearwater offer gluten-free or vegan options?
Many pizza restaurants in Clearwater cater to special diets. Popular spots like Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, Johnny’s Italian Restaurant, and Gondolier Pizza offer gluten-free and vegan selections, so you won’t feel left out if you skip classic dough or cheese.
2. Which Clearwater pizzerias are open late?
Plenty of local favorites stay open for the night crowd. King’s Pizza, Mellow Mushroom, and Five Star Pizza all serve slices well after sundown—perfect for beachgoers or night owls searching for a late bite.
3. Are there authentic Italian pizzerias in Clearwater?
Clearwater is home to several authentic Italian pizza spots. Cristino’s Coal Oven Pizza, Johnny’s Italian Restaurant, Al & Stella Authentic Italian Restaurant, and Gondolier Pizza stand out for their time-honored recipes and traditional flavors.
4. Can I find pizza delivery in Clearwater?
Yes, almost all major pizza shops in Clearwater offer delivery, from locally owned gems like Monty’s Pizza and Country Pizza Italian Grill to national favorites including Domino’s and Five Star Pizza.
5. What are some kid-friendly pizza places in Clearwater?
Family-friendly options abound. Spots like CiCi’s Pizza, Juke Pizza And Games, Roundabout Pizza, and Boardwalk Pizza & Gyros have comfortable settings and crowd-pleasing menus for pizza fans of all ages.