Finding truly great pizza in Wasilla feels almost like a local sport. It’s the kind of quest where every Alaskan has at least one strong opinion and a go-to recommendation tucked away. Pizza here isn’t just food, it’s a comfort on a rainy evening, a quick refuel after hiking the Butte, or the reason friends gather to share a few slices and a lot of stories. Over the years, I’ve learned that each spot in Wasilla has its own flavor, its own crowd, and more than a few secrets to share.
This guide comes straight from sitting in booths, grabbing takeout, and chatting with folks who know the pizza landscape better than anyone—people who care about a perfect crust as much as the topping. If you’re hoping to discover where the ooey-gooey cheese stretches or which place serves up the crispiest base, you’re in exactly the right place. Dive in, and let’s find your new favorite slice in Wasilla together.
1. Cadillac Cafe
Stepping into Cadillac Cafe, you immediately sense its charm—a retro roadside feel with a modern twist. What sets Cadillac apart is attention to detail, right down to the crust. I still remember the first time I tried their signature pizza: crisp edges, creative toppings, and a sauce with a little zing.
This spot caters to everyone, with vegetarian, vegan, and gluten-free pizzas that actually taste good. Try the Veggie Delight or their savory Margherita. They’re generous with vegetables, and the cheese blend stretches just right.
Lunch or dinner feels relaxed and unrushed, whether you sit in or grab a slice to go. For Wasilla locals, Cadillac is more than a pit stop—it’s a favorite for fresh pizza made with care.
2. Locals Pub and Pizzeria
Locals Pub and Pizzeria lives up to its name—walk in, and you’ll notice familiar faces chatting over fresh pies and cold drinks. The vibe here is casual, with a hint of hometown pride and always-friendly service. On busy nights, the smell of pizza in the air is enough to make anyone hungry.
Locals is known for creative yet reliable pies. My favorite is the Mediterranean, loaded with crisp vegetables and tangy feta. The crust is thin but sturdy, and gluten-free options mean no one is left out. Try pairing a classic pepperoni pizza with one of their specialty sodas for an ideal combo.
If you’re after a spot that feels like it’s run by neighbors, this is the one. The pizza never disappoints.
3. Larson’s Pizza Joint
Larson’s Pizza Joint is a reliable local fixture that knows exactly how to please a crowd. With their classic pies and friendly staff, Larson’s leans into comfort—fresh dough, hot cheese, and an oven working overtime during the dinner rush. It’s the kind of place where kids celebrate soccer wins and families gather after a long week.
I’ve never left disappointed. Their Supreme Pizza showcases Larson’s knack for layering fresh veggies and just the right amount of sauce. Order one of the custom combos if you’re feeling adventurous—each is crafted with care and plenty of flavor.
Delivery, table service, or takeout all run smoothly. If you want classic pizza done right, with a local twist, Larson’s should top your list every time you’re in Wasilla.
4. Papa Johns Pizza
+1 907-357-7272
Papa Johns Pizza in Wasilla nails consistency, offering the same familiar bite whether you’re eating in Anchorage or right here on Parks Highway. The fresh dough and signature sweet sauce are a cut above other national chains, always arriving hot and loaded with customizable toppings.
Order the classic Garden Fresh or try their thin-crust Cheese for a lighter feel. Every slice delivers Papa Johns’ trademark blend: reliable, gooey cheese and crust with a satisfying chew. It’s easy comfort food when you’re craving something you know will hit the spot.
Carryout is quick, and delivery rarely leaves you waiting. Papa Johns makes it simple to get crowd-pleasing pizza in Wasilla, any day of the week.
5. Pizza King
Pizza King adds a playful twist to the Wasilla pizza scene—think hearty portions, creative combos, and a menu that stretches from breakfast to dinner. This place isn’t flashy, but the warm, friendly vibe keeps you coming back. I once lingered over brunch here, and the staff made sure everyone left with a smile and a full belly.
Their Greek Veggie pizza stands out, loaded with olives, peppers, and a generous layer of cheese. If you’re in the mood for a true king-sized pie, go big with their Big Kahuna—always fresh and satisfying.
Pizza King delivers, offers table service, and is equally perfect for takeout if you’re on the move. Expect slices with substance and a local touch.
6. Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘n’ Bake Pizza
Papa Murphy’s | Take ‘n’ Bake Pizza flips the script by handing you a pizza to finish at home. The dough is always soft and fresh, and the toppings look as vibrant as any fine-dining spot. There’s something special about sliding your own custom pie into the oven and catching that aroma in your kitchen.
The Cowboy pizza is popular for a reason: it’s loaded, rich, and bakes up with a crisp bottom every time. If you’ve got dietary needs, Papa Murphy’s covers those bases, too. Everything is made to order, so no surprises when you open the box.
This spot is ideal if you want the freshest possible pizza on your own schedule—a genuinely fun way to enjoy dinner in Wasilla.
7. Pizza Hut
Pizza Hut in Wasilla brings a bit of nostalgia to every table, the kind that goes back to childhood birthday parties and spur-of-the-moment pizza nights. The crust—the classic Pan style, thick and golden—continues to set Pizza Hut apart. It’s a familiar crunch and bite that regulars, including me, keep coming back for.
The Veggie Lovers pizza is a reliable go-to. Crisp peppers, mushrooms, and just enough mozzarella to hold it all together. Stuffed Crust is always a crowd-pleaser if you crave that extra cheesy edge. There’s something special about that signature sauce, tangy and robust, which pairs perfectly with any topping combo.
Ordering is a breeze, dine-in or takeout, and Pizza Hut’s consistency shines. When comfort is the goal, the Hut never disappoints.
8. Marcello’s Restaurant
Marcello’s Restaurant adds a little bit of Italy to Wasilla. The pizza here stands out for its attention to tradition—thin, slightly charred crusts and toppings that taste like they came straight from the garden. The mood is relaxed but with a touch of old-school elegance, whether you’re dining in or picking up a pie to go.
The Margherita at Marcello’s is a true showcase, with basil and fresh mozzarella melting into a light, flavorful sauce. If you prefer something heartier, try the Four Cheese; it’s rich, creamy, and perfectly baked.
Service is prompt and a bit more personal than you might expect. For a pizza night that feels just a step above, Marcello’s never misses the mark.
9. Leo’s Döner Kebab & Pizzeria
Leo’s Döner Kebab & Pizzeria blends Mediterranean flair with classic pizza comfort. The cozy, colorful setting stands out in Wasilla, and so does the menu. Here, you’ll find pizzas with unexpected twists—think unique herbs and bold flavors instead of just the usual fare.
The Mediterranean Veggie pizza deserves a mention. It’s loaded with peppers, olives, and just the right touch of feta for brightness. Every bite feels fresh, the crust is thin but sturdy, and the balance of seasonings sets Leo’s apart from standard pizzerias.
If you’re craving pizza that’s both familiar and a little adventurous, Leo’s delivers on both fronts. It’s a genuine local favorite for when you want something out of the ordinary.
10. Sicilys Pizza
Sicilys Pizza brings a taste of tradition to Wasilla, focusing on hearty portions and flavor-packed pies. The sauce stands out most—zesty, slightly sweet, and never overpowers the toppings. I remember my first bite of their Veggie Pizza: generous layers of fresh vegetables over a doughy, golden base.
Their crust has a great chew, and you can tell it’s made in-house. If you want something that feels extra special, try one of their signature combos. Delivery and takeout are prompt, keeping the pizza just as warm as if you were dining in the shop.
Sicilys is perfect when you want pizza that fills you up without feeling too heavy—true comfort food, Wasilla style.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best places for pizza in Wasilla, AK?
The best spots include Cadillac Cafe, Locals Pub and Pizzeria, Larson’s Pizza Joint, Marcello’s Restaurant, and Sicilys Pizza. Each offers a unique spin on classic pies.
Are there vegetarian or gluten-free pizza options in Wasilla?
Yes, most major pizzerias—like Cadillac Cafe and Locals Pub and Pizzeria—have vegetarian selections and gluten-free crusts, so everyone can enjoy a slice.
Which pizza places offer delivery in Wasilla?
Sicilys Pizza, Pizza Hut, Papa Johns, Papa Murphy’s, and Pizza King all offer reliable delivery services.
Is there a spot for take-and-bake pizza in Wasilla?
Papa Murphy’s is the top choice for take-and-bake. You pick up your pizza fresh and finish it at home.
Which pizzerias are good for families or groups?
Larson’s Pizza Joint, Pizza King, and Pizza Hut are favorites for groups thanks to large tables, generous portions, and shareable combos.
Can I find pizza places open for lunch and dinner?
Almost every pizzeria in Wasilla serves both lunch and dinner, so you can get your fix any time of day.