If you think pizza in Cleveland is just an afterthought between sports games, think again. This city takes its slices seriously. I still remember ducking into a tucked-away spot on a rainy evening, only to have a chewy, blistered crust and tangy sauce completely reroute my plans for the night. It taught me early on: in Cleveland, pizza isn’t just food—it’s a local obsession, and the best pies come with their own stories.
Cleveland’s pizza scene is eclectic, bold, and—most importantly—delicious. Craving classic New York-style pies? Or do you lean towards bubbly Neapolitan? Maybe you want something uniquely Cleveland. Lucky for you, each pizzeria on this list adds its own spin, serving up slices that range from the tried-and-true to the entirely unexpected. Ready to skip the guesswork and land yourself a seriously satisfying pizza? This guide will point you straight to the kind of pie worth chasing down.
Where to find the best pizza in Cleveland, OH
Here are some of the top spots to find the best pizza in Cleveland, OH:
- Masthead Brewing Co.
- Mama Santa’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
- Citizen Pie
- Saucy Brew Works
- Pizza 216
- Geraci’s Restaurant
- Il Rione
- Pizza Whirl
- Crust
- Maxi’s Bistro
1. Masthead Brewing Co.
Masthead Brewing Co. combines industrial-cool vibes with some of the best wood-fired pizza around. Whenever I slip into their airy taproom, the scent of crisping dough and charred edges almost makes me forget they’re just as serious about their brews as their pies.
Their approach takes cues from the best Neapolitan traditions, yet keeps things inventive and fresh. A favorite? The “Spicy Soppressata,” with its generous layer of cheese and a balanced heat that lingers.
If you prefer something lighter, their Margherita is a classic—a chewy crust, fresh mozzarella, and a pop of basil. Don’t skip the creative vegetarian options either, which celebrate local produce and big flavors.
Masthead doesn’t just serve pizza; it elevates the simple pie into something memorable for the city’s food lovers.
2. Mama Santa’s Restaurant and Pizzeria
Walking into Mama Santa’s feels a bit like being handed a piece of Cleveland’s past. Family photos, bustling tables, and the faint aroma of tomatoes signal you’re about to eat real Italian comfort food. I’ve sat by the window here more than once, watching locals greet the owners like old friends.
The crust at Mama Santa’s carries a secret: it’s both crisp beneath and satisfyingly airy. Their square-cut pizza, heavy with gooey mozzarella and bright tomato sauce, keeps regulars coming back. “The Veggie Special” is always a smart choice for its fresh toppings and rich flavor profile.
Simplicity shines here—the Margherita is a classic study in balance, and the cheese pizza doesn’t try to outdo itself. Mama Santa’s keeps it genuine, and in Cleveland, that still matters.
3. Citizen Pie
There’s a certain energy at Citizen Pie that makes each pizza feel like a fresh discovery. The first time I stopped in, I watched the pizzaiolos work dough and flames like an art form—you taste that skill with every bite. Their wood-fired oven brings out intense flavors and a delicate, leopard-spotted crust that’s impossible to forget.
Try the “Spicy Pepperoni” or “Margherita,” both showcasing Citizen Pie’s love for simple, big flavors. The sauce isn’t buried in cheese; it shines through, highlighting just how good fresh tomatoes can be. Vegan and vegetarian options hold their own here, making everyone happy without compromise.
Each visit is a reminder that Cleveland’s pizza scene is thriving—thanks in no small part to spots like Citizen Pie.
4. Saucy Brew Works
Saucy Brew Works is every bit as lively as its name suggests. My favorite seat is near their huge windows, perfect for people watching while the kitchen turns out bubbling, golden-edged pies. This spot pairs its inventive pizza menu with house-brewed beers, but even without the pints, their pizzas would still take center stage.
The “Bee’s Knees” pizza stands out, layering tangy tomato sauce, stretchy cheese, and a drizzle of local honey for an unexpected kick. Prefer classic comforts? The Margherita and Veggie options pack flavor into every slice, thanks to a chewy crust and garden-fresh toppings.
Saucy Brew Works makes each pizza joyful and approachable—perfect for a fun, relaxed night out in Cleveland.
5. Pizza 216
Pizza 216 delivers serious flavor with an upscale twist—perfect for downtown pizza lovers who appreciate some style with their slice. I first stumbled in after work and was immediately drawn to the lively crowd and the remarkable aroma of fresh dough meeting the oven. The historic Arcade backdrop adds a touch of old Cleveland charm, making it easy to linger here over a second slice.
Pepperoni or Margherita keep things classic, but the “Veg Head” pizza shows off what a medley of fresh toppings can do. The crust strikes a fine balance: chewy without being heavy, sturdy but not stiff.
Whether grabbing lunch or settling in for late-night eats, Pizza 216 keeps quality high and flavors bold. Each slice tells you why they’re a Cleveland favorite.
6. Geraci’s Restaurant
Walking into Geraci’s is like getting a warm, genuine welcome from Cleveland itself. Family-run for decades, it’s where I learned that local loyalty is earned one crispy crust at a time. The charm of this spot is in its no-fuss, classic pies—generous with toppings and always cooked just right.
The “Vegetarian Pizza” offers a fresh medley while the cheese pizza proves simplicity often speaks the loudest. You’ll taste a tangy, well-balanced sauce and cheese that melts together for that perfect bite. It’s the kind of pizza you remember after every visit.
Cash only keeps things old-school, but that’s part of Geraci’s draw. Skip the fuss, savor the slice, and see why this place is treasured on the east side of Cleveland.
7. Il Rione
Il Rione feels like a neighborhood pizzeria straight out of an Italian movie—brick walls, vintage playlists, and the kind of energy that feels both relaxed and a little bit glamorous. My first visit landed me in a cozy corner with friends and a pizza that truly hit every note: blistered crust, rich sauce, and gorgeously charred cheese.
The “White Pie” is a quiet standout, packing flavor with roasted garlic and fresh herbs, while the classic Margherita highlights what a simple blend of high-quality ingredients can accomplish. Vegetarian options are inventive, always celebrating what’s fresh and in season.
Il Rione serves up pizza that makes you press pause on conversation, just to appreciate the moment. In a city full of choices, this slice is pure, crave-worthy Cleveland.
8. Pizza Whirl
Pizza Whirl brings speed and great flavor together, perfect for anyone craving a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner. I’ve dashed in more than once between errands and found myself lingering, thanks to the aroma of bubbling cheese and their easygoing style. This spot nails build-your-own pizzas, offering quality and freshness in every bite.
The white pizza with spinach and roasted veggies is a personal favorite—creamy, bright, and satisfying. Their classic cheese and pepper pizzas show off a robust sauce and a perfectly chewy crust, proving you don’t need flash for fantastic results.
With fair prices and welcoming staff, Pizza Whirl is the definition of easy, honest pizza in the heart of Cleveland.
9. Crust
Crust carves out its own space on Professor Ave with standout pies and a style that’s both comfortingly familiar and satisfyingly bold. My first slice here set the bar high—the crust really is the star: thick, chewy, and just crisp enough on the edge to stand up to even the sauciest toppings.
One to try? The “Basil Pesto Veggie” piles on fresh vegetables and zippy sauce for a bite that’s bright and layered. Their classic Margherita feels like a little trip to Italy with each mouthful.
Generous portions are standard, making it great for sharing (or not, if you’re feeling protective). With reliable delivery and a cozy dine-in, Crust is a go-to for pizza purists and explorers alike.
10. Maxi’s Bistro
Maxi’s Bistro captures the energy of Little Italy while adding its own flair to Cleveland’s pizza scene. I found myself at their garden patio one evening, caught between lively chatter and the smell of baking dough—this place is a favorite for a reason. Maxi’s isn’t just about atmosphere; the pizzas deliver on every level.
Try the classic Margherita or Veggie Pizza, both feature generous layers of fresh mozzarella, ripe tomatoes, and crisp basil. The crust has that perfect hint of chew, and the balance of flavors lands just right every time.
For a heartier bite, the Bianca holds its own—rich cheeses and a whisper of garlic. Whether pre-concert or post-game, Maxi’s Bistro makes pizza the highlight of any outing in Little Italy.
More Things to Try in Cleveland, OH
Frequently Asked Questions
What types of pizza styles can I find in Cleveland?
Cleveland’s pizza scene features everything from classic New York-style and thin Neapolitan to thick, chewy Sicilian and unique local creations. There’s something for everyone, no matter your crust or topping preference.
Are there vegetarian and vegan pizza options in Cleveland?
Absolutely. Many top spots offer vegetarian pies stacked with veggies, and several now feature vegan cheese or entirely plant-based options for those skipping dairy.
What are the best areas to find great pizza in Cleveland?
Neighborhoods like Little Italy, Ohio City, Tremont, and Downtown boast an impressive collection of standout pizzerias, each worth exploring for their own specialties and atmospheres.
Do Cleveland pizzerias offer gluten-free options?
Yes, quite a few local favorites accommodate gluten-free diners with crusts that don’t compromise on flavor or texture.
Is takeout or delivery widely available?
Most pizza spots in Cleveland offer both takeout and delivery, making it easy to satisfy your cravings whether you’re at home or on the go.